Customer Reviews Birkenstock Buckley - Oiled Leather

This was disappointing. Usually I love Berkinstock these were way too narrow and a full size smaller than the other styles. I'll be going back to the old styles.

These were much bigger than my other narrow 39. I think one of the two shoes might be a regular. They run at least 1/2 size larger. I'm hoping the size smaller will be a better match up.

Didn't fir. Much too large.

I’ve had 3-4 prs of Birks but these are the most uncomfortable shoes. I thought I had to break them in little but the soles have a weird footbed and the elastic strap is way too tight (and I don’t have fat feet). I do not recommend

These shoes look great on the feet. Very stylish but I was very disappointed with how uncomfortable they are. The material rubs the top of the foot which hurt on the first step. Also, the way the elastic is set on the top makes the shoe very awkward to walk in.

Really like this shoe, but the right shoe fit perfectly and was very comfortable while the left shoe did not fit. The elastic across the top was too tight and left a raw spot on top of arch. Someone else wrote about this in their review and can't help but think I received their return, especially since the shoe did not arrive in a Birkenstock shoe box, but in a plastic bag without the usual paper stuffing. Quite disappointing. Will be returning the Buckley gray taupe.

The shoe looks so cute and is marked “narrow”. Not narrow enough, even with wool socks. I returned these and will try a different style. I love the Mayari sandal in 40N and had hoped these would fit as well. I’ve ordered the Oswego and hope for better luck.

It was really narrow. I could get it on my foot, but barely. I sure wish they made these to fit like the regular Birkenstocks.

I live in Birkenstocks and was excited to have a pair for fall. These are waaayy too wide for my narrow feet and the buckle didn't help. If your feet are like mine, you may have to stick with styles that have two adjustable straps. I think people with regular width feet could try these since the footbed is wider than a typical narrow. Avoid if you have really wide feet though.

Shoe didn't even fit on my foot it was so narrow and I don't generally buy wide shoes. Love the support of birkenstocks but had to return these unfortunately.

Frustrating time with this purchase. Loved the style. Color is awesome. Sizing is crazy. Normally I wear a 7. Size 38 was so large, I could walk right out of them. Size 37 was was too small and super narrow. Thank goodness for Zappos superior customer service and generous return policy. Both pairs went back and no new birkies for me?

I wear Romika and Naot and was looking for a slide to wear with winter socks. I am 5'10" tall and wear a size 11narrow. Unfortunately, my foot volume is way too thin/low for these shoes. The length was ok but I was swimming in the shoe even though it is marked as narrow. Consider not only the size and width but the volume of your foot if you order these.

Love the style, but right shoe was off somehow. Hell bed seemed loose/sprung on the right shoe and toes touched against the outside of shoe. Left was great, But returned rather than asking asking for an exchange.

I've never purchased a narrow width shoe before, but despite the narrow width, they were too wide! My foot slipped forward and jammed the end of the shoe. There was no way I would be able to walk in these.

I love Birkenstock sandals for the comfort so hoped these would work, but they caused blisters on the top of my feet where the strap rubbed.

Fit is why out of line foe women’s feet, they should make separate men and women’s ! Disappointed cute style

Really bummed our that Birkenstock has to make unsexiest sandals, can’t we just have a decent fit for women? I’ve worn Birkenstock for years

Very uncomfortable

wow I so wanted these to work. I love my Birkenstock sandals have 3 pair. These just did not fit for me. Tried two different sizes. So disappointed.

I was very disappointed in the color. It was much lighter than the color shown on the website. It looked like it was navy blue on the website (midnight) but it was more like a dusty blue. Also the shoes were not in a Birkenstock box. There was no literature showing it was Birkenstock. I have bought many Birkenstock shoes from Zappos and they all came in Birkenstock boxes with Birkenstock tags. I do not intend to buy any more Birkenstocks from Zappos.

I want to love this shoe. It looks great, feels great, and fits well. The problem is that the shoe has a strip of elastic at the top of the shoe, and when I walk, the shoe makes a slapping sound against the floor like a bad pair of flip flops! Step, slap. Step, slap. Step. slap .... Can't stand it and they have to go back.

They just look and feel cheap in person. Very disappointing product from Birkenstock. The Boston Clogs look significantly nicer. Returning.

I have worn a size 42N Birkenstock for 30 years. They have always fit perfectly. I measured these against my Boston clogs I bought in January and they were a full half inch shorter. I'm so bummed! They're adorable, but completely unwearable.

BEWARE FAKE BIRKENSTOCKS

This shoe is loose on the foot as it is unstructured and does not hug the foot as I am accustomed to in this brand. I have a slender foot and it may well work for a full foot. It would easily slip off my foot and certainly is not recommended for elderly even around the house. Color is nice. I am returning, thank you Zappos, for your liberal return policy.