Customer Reviews Madewell The vernon loafer in leather

I must have ordered 20 different loafers between last season and this year. FINALLY, I found one I LOVE that FITS! They are classy with a little funk - perfect! I stretched them a bit before wearing them for the first time (I wore extra heavy socks after heating the shoes with a blow drier). I wore them for 12 hours the first time and they felt great!

These are very very stiff and not comfortable at all.

At least half size too big. Heels slipped out when walking.

Very cute shoe. The fit was weird with one shoe being considerably tighter than the other. This is usually not a problem for me. The shoe that fits better slips but might remedy that with an insert. Just don’t want to have to mess with the shoe that is too tight.

I could not even get my foot in these. Very small

I think these are the worst shoes I've ever purchased. They are very loud and "clompy" and they creased oddly the very first time I wore them (picture is after a single day). I should have taken a clue from the fact that the first pair I ordered arrived damaged with a similar type of crease. They weren't cheap, but I doubt I'll continue to wear them. They are that bad. Or they were for me. I thought maybe by writing a review I could spare somebody else!

Extremely uncomfortable and never broke-in, even after two months of wear. These are very shallow across the top of the toe box and caused me so much pain—actually began to develop a “tailors bunion” on one foot due to wearing these shoes. Sad because they were the best looking of the many many pairs I tried!

These shoes are hideous. Nor are they shiny as depicted which might have helped their appearance.