Customer Reviews Madewell The Nettie Heeled Mary Jane in Leather

First I have to say these MJ’s have great style and were comfortable right out of the box! I’m a guy and always wear a womens 10M or 41 euro and these have ample room in the toe box and the 2 inch heel is the perfect height. Most of all I love the two narrow straps that accent this Mary Jane style. Don’t believe all the negative reviews, buy them and try’em on, you can always send them back if you need to.

Adorable but super stiff. Had to go back.

I have two pairs of this shoe - one in silver leather and one in black leather. These shoes are incredibly stylish AND comfortable. The heel height is perfect for slacks or jeans or skirts or dresses. I am drawn to Mary Jane pumps as they stay on my feet and have a French Girl vibe. I was so excited to find this style from Madewell at an excellent price. I have a red patent leather pair from Carel, a French company, that are more than double this price. These are equally comfortable and stylish. I normally wear a 7.5, but sized up to an 8 for these and they are very comfortable. love wearing these pumps.

Hey. These are great shoes. Look like Prada from a few seasons ago snd their current Mary Jane sling back. Comfy snd love the leather lining and insole. Grab a pair. You won’t be disappointed!!

Fit well, just not the right style for my moderately wide feet. They fit and were comfortable, but to really pull off the French village style, I think you need a really slender foot to keep that elegant line, which I do not have. The shoe sort of bowed out at the widest part of my foot and it just wasn't the super sleek look I hoped for.

I was very hesitant to purchase these shoes since some of the reviews complained about fit, comfort, and quality. I am delighted to say that they fit great, are super comfortable right out of the box, and have no quality issues. I’ve gotten lots of compliments at the office about how cute they are. I did go up a half size to accommodate my wide width at the toes and glad that I did.

Love these shoes! Quality leather and a great fit. Unfortunately, I had to return them as someone had stretched out the strap and Zappos does not have another pair in my size.

i searched for the perfect mary jane for months and finally found it with these. the heel is the perfect height to dress up or down and the double-buckle is so cute. when my girlfriend saw them her jaw dropped. i’ve worn them for shorter holiday outings and they’re pretty comfy. very happy with this purchase so far.

Love the style, but tight in the toe box. Hopefully they stretch out a bit.

The leather was stiff and cut into my feet and style didn’t work with the dress I wanted them for. Si they went back.

Felt a little tight on my toes. Returned. TTS. I have narrow feet.

very uncomfortable and stiff leather. returning. Bought the same shoe in suede- great!

I did not receive this order.