Customer Reviews VIONIC Cheryl II

Absolutely love this classy lug loafer. Sadly though I found them too long for my foot, so they had to go back. For reference, my feet are wide at the front, with a narrow heel. The toe box was just wide enough, but my heel slipped so badly I wouldn't be able to actually walk in them. I ordered (and generally wear) the regular width. I tried the same size in the Wide but it was enormous. I would have liked to try 1/2 size smaller in the Wide, but it was unavailable. Sad to give them up, but they aren't going to work. Great style. Wish they'd worked.

Great arch support. Weird fit. Too wide. They look better in photos. The proportions are off with these shoes. They’re def going back.

Very long - full size larger than my normal size.

Not sure what’s going on with Vionic lately. I own several pairs of Vionic shoes and sandals and normally need to size down 1/2 size. Both the lace up booties and these loafers run long and narrow, even the wide fits narrower than a normal medium. Disappointed because the booties and the loafers are stylish and super light weigh. Sizing up doesn’t work because you just gain length without width. I took the inserts out which helped roominess wise but a no go without arch support.

I wish this shoe worked for me, but the length was too long and and they were too wide.

These are lovely loafers with good support. I ordered my usual size in Vionic and my heal walks out of these.

My regular size is 8.5. I had to size down to 8. Width fine

I read several reviews that said these shoes run long so I ordered my normal size (8) and a 1/2 size smaller. No idea why some feel these run long. The fit was perfect. Kept the 8 in tan, returned the 7.5 in black and got the 8. LOVE them. Have worn them both already and they feel great on the first wear. So comfy I don't immediately feel like I need to kick them off when I get home from work. Win.

Love these loafers. I originally purchased in my normal size 9.5 but per other reviewers, this shoe ran quite large. It was too long but also had a huge gap over my foot. I sized down to a 9 and they are PERFECT! These loafers have excellent support and less than 30 min out of box had molded to my feet. I do have thin ankle bones and normal width feet. The toe box was fine for me but would definitely be too tight for wider toe spreads. Thanks Zappos for the easy purchase and returns so that I can wear a great pair of supportive shoes!

These had decent support but were too long, my heel kept slipping.

I normally wear a size 8 1/2 in Vionic, but my feet were swimming in these shoes. Had to return

nice leather and good looking shoe. Great support as always from Vionic. I thought they were a half size small but maybe that's bc my foot runs a little wide

I have three pairs of Vionics loafers in the Kensley style -- nearly identical to the Cheryl II but without the "penny band" across the top -- all in 7.5 W. (My size usually is 8W, but sometimes is 7.5W.) The 7.5W in the Cheryl II, however, was too small. I would have exchanged it for a half size larger, but decided to get the blue Kensley instead, which I know will fit correctly. The Cheryl II is very cute and I expect the half size larger would be just as comfortable as the Kensley.

These were just too narrow on the toes. I do have a wide toe spread from many years of wearing flip flops and Birkenstocks.

Super cute - good fit but a bit narrow for my oddly duck shaped foot. Wide in the front and narrow heel :(

I guess this must be true to width because it is marked a B, but unfortunately for me, I have very long narrow feet, and finding a shoe that works is all but impossible. If it doesn't tie, it doesn't stay on. These looked like they might work in the picture but I took one step and walked out of them. I would have loved to have been able to keep them, but sadly, back they go.

Trust the reviews! I am usually 8-8.5, and due to foot issues have been ordering wide and/or a half size up (so 8.5-9). I ordered these in an 8W and they are way way too big. Returning and trying a 7.5 in both M and W., hoping one of those will work. They are cute on, and the footbed seems super comfy, but huge! Note, I live in a warm climate, so generally only wearing thin socks/sock liners.

I own a pair of Ionic sneakers that I love. I was looking forward to these loafers but unfortunately I slipped out of the size 7 (my usual size) and the size 6.5 was too narrow on my toe area. Note that I am starting to have a bunion so I can't wear shoes that are too stiff. Otherwise, they look great and are well made. I would recommend them for business casual wear and for people with fairly narrow feet.

Cute shoes, but a full size too large. I usually wear a size 8W, but these felt a full size too large. The material felt a little stiff. I'm not sure if it would soften up with wear because it was so large that I could not walk in them (my heel just kept slipping out). Though the heel on these is really cute, the flat Vionic Uptown loafer had softer suede and felt more comfortable. (It ran a half size too large so I had to size down to a 7.5W in that shoe).

I wanted to LOVE these shoes but I had to return. The toe box was so narrow that my feet were super uncomfortable. If not for that I loved the look and the arch support. I hope these work for you b/c they are so cute!

I agree with previous reviews. I loved the toe box of this shoe, but the heel slipped for me. I do not usually have this problem so it must be in the design. It is really cute and comfortable. Too bad it has to go back.

I loved the quality and style of these shoes. Unfortunately the fit wasn't right for my feet. Normally I buy an 8. I always need wide and rarely find them, so I ordered an 8W. They are too long and slip easily on my heel and for me they didn't feel like a wide width. Because they don't fit properly it's hard to say if the arch support was sufficient. But I love my other Vionic shoes. I'm sad to have to return them but so happy Zappos offers such a generous return policy.

As many people have said, in my normal size there is a large gap at the heel and my foot slips out. I tried a half size smaller but that was too small. I think I will try to keep them and get some thick heel grip cushions for the back and hope they work.

Toe box too narrow