Customer Reviews Madewell The Bradley Lugsole Loafer in Leather

These are the cutest shoes and the leather is very nice. Unfortunately, the sizing and cut are way off. In the 8.5 my foot was slipping out of the back and the shoes felt super big. I tried the 8 and I could barely get my foot in the shoe. Hopefully they can get the sizing and cut right and make this again next year. For now I had to return them.

Great looking lugsole, not so large and heavy as other models. very comfortable. My feet are slightly wide and I needed to wear them several times before they were perfectly comfortable.

This shoe runs just a bit large and slipped on my heel. It's also pretty heavy, but that's usually the case with lugsoles. Looked great on, though!

Beautiful shoe - just runs narrow

The leather on this shoe was beautiful. The only issue with the shoe is that my heal slipped, therefore I had to return them.

I felt like I was wearing my father's shoes when I tried these on. I realize they're part of a new style and they look great on even the skinniest models but not on me -- and I'm pretty slender. The leather is very soft however, and the shoes should be comfortable if the style suits you! (The shoe are not as pointed as it looks in the pic.)

Beautiful shoes and comfortable from day one.

Extremely heavy. Feels like walking with blocks on my feet. Too bad because I like the look but they are going back.

I wanted to like these, but they fit both long and wide. The leather was nice but the sizing was a no-go for me.

Even if this shoe fit well I would still be returning it. I ordered the chestnut in size 11 M, my usual size. The heel area fit well, but the toe box was a bit too narrow. The color is a flat brown with some orange undertones. It looks like a man’s shoe. The lug sole makes it pretty heavy. Unfortunately it has to go back

Disappointed that the right foot of the shoes came in defective, in different spots.

Too tight.