Customer Reviews Madewell The Carina Platform Chelsea Boot

True to size, so comfortable wore all day to a theme park w my 3 kids! Nice narrow shape, not big & clunky like some rubber sole shoes out on the market. These are more feminine in my opinion.

They are too narrow for me and my bunion. The leather is extremely stiff. I liked the look of them, I have to send them back.

Love the black platform lug sole and off-white ivory leather. Seems to be very good quality. I have a medium to narrow width foot and they fit closely but not uncomfortably so, even with socks. Sole is well cushioned. Will go with so many outfits and the sale price is awesome. A keeper for me.

I couldn't walk in them because my heels kept slipping out. And they are very stiff feeling.

Boots bottom is extremely stiff and large heel slip on spot so the foot pops up and down

Love these booties from madewell. Love the color. Love the heel

Perfect! Stylish, durable, comfortable

Felt stiff at first but definitely softened in a day or so. The platform is not too chunky.

These were very stylist platform boots. Very beautiful boots. Material and structure very well made. Unfortunately, the size ran a bit short on my foot. I accidentally returned them to Amazon so I’m out of the cost which I paid for them boo-hoo.

These were definitely narrow, as others have said and need to be broken in around the house before wearing out. If you're in between sizes I would err on the larger side. I love the style and the added height from the platform heel since I'm kind of a short person. These feel a bit more dressy and feminine than other Chelsea boots.

I love the look of these boots. I normally wear size 81/2 but had to return as I could barely squeeze my feet in. Size 9 is perfect. The boots do seem a bit stiff and the left boot rubs against my leg but I’m keeping them because they look good!! They’re not too chunky and very stylish!

On the fence about these. TTS. More taupe than white. A little narrow in the toe, stiff overall, slip up and down some on the heel. That being said, seem like good quality materials and construction and I like the look.

The boot was very stiff, and had very little cushion, super cute, but not comfortable

I think I am between the 8.5 and 9 on these, as I often am. The 8.5's are tremendously narrow for me, so I'd need the 9's, but my feet come out of the heel of the 9's as I walk in normal socks.

I really like how these boots look, and I like how they feel on my right foot. The left foot is a bit too narrow across the widest part of my foot. I am going to try the stretching hack where you put on heavy socks, squish your feet into the boots, and use a blow dryer to warm the area where the boot is tight, while wiggling my foot.