Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds Randolph

I have two pairs and plan to get a spring color this year. Great fit, meets many different needs and always gets positive comments.

I had to send the first pair back and order a half size down. Customer service on The return was great. The shoes look and feel fantastic.

Solid shoe with solid shoe attributes, there's a text minimum here

I live all AE shoes. My closet has at least 6 or 7 pair. Comfortable, great leather. As close to a custom made shoe there is.

I have had Allen Edmonds shoes for the past 20 years or so. Just bought a new pair in the past month. As always, love them! Great shoes. And last forever, almost, due to the shoe rehab service! Love that too!

First one had quality issues - Second was perfect. It is not the first time it happens with a pair of AE but thanks to the size that I got it wrong, changed to E from D, second pair came perfect. Shoes are amazing am supper happy now. Love AE return system. Works fantastic.

It was time to add a much needed staple loafer and what better selection than AE Randolph in Coffee, the fit and finish are amazing, a charming shoe.

Just got these today in walnut. Great fit, comfortable right out of the box. Beautiful, classy leather. I intend to wear them with everything from suits=, to khakis, to jeans!

Love this shoe. Went in store and was fitted. Fit is perfect. Bought Coffee color with matching belt and it works great for my business casual environment. Will be buying a black pair soon. Would also buy oxblood if they do another run of them.

This show was comfortable straight out of the box. The classic look is timeless. Also appreciate the speedy shipping

High quality is worth the price. Craftsmen who care about long term customer relationships!

Comfortable, sleek loafer. I wear them with and without socks. Highly recommend in brown.

Allen-Edmonds are the best value, great quality. I'm a 9.5 and they are true to size. Own a number of Allen-Edmonds and they all track to my size. Added the Dainite black rubber sole which is great on wet surfaces.

The fit is perfect. The service was great. The shoe is comfortable. The material is beautiful. Thank you.

Beautiful, comfortable and classy loafer. Must have in any closet!

For many years all I have worn is Allen-Edmons. I need a 9EE and they are note the easiest to find. One of my friends introduced me to A-E 30years ago. This was my first Penny Loafer & I love them. Fit great and feel good. I expected nothing less! Very happy with my purchase.

I bought these about 2 months ago and have worn them a couple times. I both love the look, style and comfort. So glad I bought these and recommend them as part of your wardrobe!!

Bought these for my husband's birthday to have in our FL hime. He has always worn Allen Edmunds so I knew what I was buying. They are classic and be worn with a suit or khakis. Nice style!

I have weird shaped feet. I just can't get around it. I wear a quadruple E width with an 8 1/2 length. I've had problems with shoes all my life. These are simply fantastic. I feel great and look great, I'm looking forward to keeping them for years..

The shoes seemed to run a full size larger than most all other AE shoes I own..

I wear a 12.5 or 13 wide in most brands, including other AE loafers and oxfords, but I've gone tried everything from 13 down to 12 and they all fit like boats. Still trying to find the right fit because they look great.

Shoes run much bigger than expected. Had to use tongue insert to fit

These shoes are OK; not great. I took them to my cobbler right out of the box to have sole protectors put on them. While examining the shoes he asked twice whether they were factory seconds and when I replied that they were not he asked, "Are you sure?". To be clear, the shoes I purchased were full price from a brick and mortar storefront. They aren't bad shoes, but they certainly aren't what I (used) to expect from Allen Edmonds. They just aren't the shoes they were a generation ago.