Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Jildie

I was so afraid these would pinch, be too tall and uncomfortable to walk in, etc. However, these shoes were too adorable for me to pass up on. So glad I took the gamble because they turned out to be comfortable and beautiful! I am anywhere from a 7.5 to 8, so I bought the 8 in case they pinch anywhere. There's some space in the back, but otherwise fit perfectly (see photo). Now that I've found my holy grail heel, I will definitely be buying in more colors!

This Mary Jane is sturdy as well as beautiful. I plan to wear them dressed up and with jeans.

I love these shoes. I normally wear a 6 in Edelman. I did need a 6.5 in these. Please, make these in black. I would buy them in a heartbeat!

This is the prettiest Mary Jane ever. The color is such a pretty neutral pink. So girly-sexy and classic. These shoes look great with everything and class up an outfit! They are also very comfortable with the wider toe box and solid heel and strap. There is no toe cleavage.

I absolutely love these shoes. An updated retro feel. Also, very comfortable.

Stylish and comfortable shoes. Have in 3 color. I love it . Thanks Sam Edelman

I bought 2 pairs of these and as other reviewers have said on 3 separate websites, they squeak with every single step and it does not diminish. You may not hear it outdoors or at an event but should you wear them to work in a quieter office (as I did), they are embarrassingly loud. I was able to return one pair but not the ones I wore to work as they are now 'worn'. Though it states they are leather, the squeaking made me wonder if they were perhaps not.

I love them and received many compliments! The cocoa color is great for pairing with orange, tan, beige, and even denim.

So cute and comfortable! Very true to size! I'm super pleased with these!!

Fit great and look amazing! They're so cute and I'm glad i got them.

I love this shoe so much I bought two different colors. Fits well exact size. Looks amazing on my feet. I get so many compliments especially on the Blue ones.

Love this shoe! Fit is true to size. Comfortable and looks great with office clothes or jeans.

Great shoe. Very comfortable and looks amazing with everything.

I honestly never write reviews online but I wore these shoes for the first time last night and I just had to share. I worked an event from 6:30pm - 2:30am, on my feet, running around the entire time and they were so comfortable I was shocked. That's a good 8 hours of wear time, the FIRST time I wore them. No socks, no breaking in needed. I am blown away! You need these shoes.

Super comfortable. Supportive. Has a distinct design which has attracted many compliments. Walked in these for miles and my feet felt perfectly alright.

I loved these so much that I ordered another pair in black. I got so many compliments on the clever blue MJ's. They are so comfortable. My new go to SF how!

These shoes are so cute and SO comfortable. The fit was perfect and I wear these all day at work without my feet hurting. Really good quality shoe.

There are gorgeous! Very versatile and comfortable.