Customer Reviews Sofft Carleigh

Nice looking shoe but no cushioning under the ball of the foot. Maybe it's me. When I was younger I wore heels all the time but I'm maybe I'm just over it. Not comfortable.

I love open toed shoes. These are comfy. I got the dark brown and they’re gorgeous. True to size, I’d say. The leather is very nice. Look best with short or cropped pants/jeans.

These are great. Soft leather right out of the box. They do fit my foot snuggly but I have a slightly wider foot. Also, I have a very high arch and you do notice the snugness at the top of the arch. I wore these around the house while cleaning. I figured they would stretch out a little because of the softness of the leather and they did a little. I think they will stretch more with wear. They are very attractive and can be worn with anything.

Sized down on these. Originally ordered my usual size 6.5, but would have been slipping and sliding. The size 6, however, is perfect. Love the shoes! They are extremely comfortable and look great on my feet. Think I'll be able to wear these pretty-much year 'round.

I wore these for the 1st time today. I was on my feet for 4 hours straight and my feet feel great… right out of the gate, these are super comfortable. I love the way they look, too. The heel is curved and interesting, adding to the overall style of the shoe. 5 STARS!

I usually don’t write reviews but these are worthy of a review. From the moment I put them on they were amazingly comfortable! I walked around all evening without a hint of discomfort. They are also super cute! I wear a 10 and the 10 fit perfectly. Buy these shoes!!

Love Sofft shoes. Usually wear a 9, saw people were sizing down, so ordered that. I had to exchange for a 9.5, and they fit well. These are a little less comfy than the other Sofft shoes I have, but love the look and the color. Haven found an open toe bootie in navy, so had to get it! Will likely buy more colors for fall. This is a great shoe with this fall’s ankle jeans!!

A classic shoe - comfortable and chic.

Such a great shoe, perfect fit and feel right out of the box. The only down side is I found them so late that I can only find one pair in my size.

I love the shoe! Very soft leather,very comfortable. After reading the reviews I did size down. I usually wear 7.5 but went with a 7. They are perfect!

True to size and the heel is not too high. Very comfortable and have worn them all day with no issue and no breaking in period.

The fit was good, loved the style, the comfort was not there. I need a shoe that has a small heel, that can be casual and/or a little bit dressy. These were perfect, except I need some padding at the ball of my foot. I wore them around the house for a little while and knew that I could never be on my feet for any great length of time, without really hurting my feet. I wanted these to work, but sadly they did not.

When I first put them on, they felt a little tight and stiff around the ankle, and I was concerned they would rub and cause blisters. I put some socks on and wore them around the house for a while, and that helped "loosen" them up a bit. They are very comfortable, have already worn a few times and very happy with purchase

Just what I needed to wear with my flared leg jeans! Great fit, comfortable as all get out and really good looking!

super and they soften right up and the second time I wore them they slipped right on

Love these shoes, but they’re too difficult for me to get on with my arthritic hands..The leather is amazing. I would keep them if I could get into them.

The suede fit completely different than the smooth leather style. It was a nice thick leather but the cut seems to be slightly off it had a gap around my upper foot area and felt stiff. Sadly they went back, it might break in but I could see several rounds of uncomfortable wear to get there.

These are a very attractive shoe, however, for me they were cut too high in the front. Felt a little tight all over. I wanted them to go with dark denim jeans, but the navy is so dark they look black. I would have kept them if they were more comfortable. I have had Sofft in the past and will try a different style.

Nice soft leather shoe. Very comfortable. I had to walk about 1/2 a mile with my first wear had no problems.

Have not worn them yet due to weather.

Perfect shoe for fall, can go from office to date night easily. Buttery soft leather and so comfy. Now to grab the other colors.

I have a high arch and was worried about the cut. But they felt fine to wear at the office.

Love these shoes, they were comfy the first day. Also pretty breathable, my feet didn't overheat in them.

The main problem was that shoes were too stiff & tight & my ankles swell

Sized down to a 6 from my usual 6.5 -- but the fit is now perfect. A great-looking bootie and very comfortable. I dropped a star because the leather by the back zipper is crumpled and has to be patted into place.