Customer Reviews PIKOLINOS Aldaya W8J-3541

I LOVED this shoe, but it did not fit me well! I found it to be tight in the toe box- very slim. Also, the style is so cute and trendy/classic. The leather was supple and comfy except for being too tight. I could not order any larger either. If you have narrow feet, this shoe might work well for you. Note- I found the shoes to be heavy too.

I love this brand, great quality and style. I have a narrow foot with a high arch, and these are comfortable, right out of the box. Highly recommend.

Very nice, well built shoes. They were just a bit too loose on my narrow heel.

These shoes are wearable right out of the box! The leather is soft, the fit is just right for my narrow heel and the color is great for fall! I really like them.

These are lovely and high-quality, but run small! I need to exchange for next size up.

I am very pleased with these shoes. It's been difficult to find a well-made loafer. I've tried other similarly-priced shoes, but these seem of much higher quality. The arch support is great and they don't slip of my heel when I'm walking. The style is classic, not especially chic, but it's a good all-around look that will go with many outfits.

Classic loafer from Pikolino. Buttery, soft leather comfortable right out of the box.

Really nice attractive well made high quality classic-but-cool shoe. I wanted it for jeans but it would go with anything. I wear a 4.5 and this was too big even with socks.

Very comfortable so far and nice quality. Appreciate that it has a removable foot bed in case I need an orthotic.

Nice well made shoes. I wear a 9 and originally ordered a size 39 but had to return for a size 40 and that size fits well.

I ordered a half size up but they are still a little tight. I'm hoping they'll stretch a little more. They are really nice shoes and I think if we can get it to stretch a little, they could be the most comfortable pair of loafers I've ever had. We'll see. I'm hopeful and would like another pair in a different color. I do love that this company has larger half sizes. Most shoes are too big or too small because I'm a half size. I pulled the liners out to see what the difference would be and they were more than roomy but I need the liners for shock absorption and comfort.

Tiny bit too tight. Otherwise would be perfect.

As usual the quality is top notch. The length was perfect. Perfect for my narrow foot. But oddly they were loose on the sides and heel. Did not feel secure while walking around the house. Otherwise super comfortable.

The fit was fine, but the shoe kept slipping off my heel making it uncomfortable to walk in.

The wrong size and wrong color of the shoe I ordered was delivered to me.

Great find, regular fit

The Pikolinos Aldaya Loafer is a beautifully crafted shoe. Unfortunately, I ordered the size 39 recommended by Zappos, rather than my usual 40. They turned out to be much too small. I was concerned that even a size up would be tight so I did not reorder this style.

Nice shoe. Runs small

Fit and size true to my expectations. Very happy with quality of shoe. Happily kept my new shoes. Chose Pikolinos because their mediums run slightly narrower than other shoe companies.

The perfect loafers! I get compliments on these all the time

True to size. Comfortable right of the box.

It’s a beautiful shoe. Very soft leather.

These shoes are ready to wear out of the box. Smart looking style, great color, true fit, they are just right!

This shoe is very comfortable. I'm sure it would be ready for walking miles without break-in time. I own a couple of other pairs of Pikolinos and the quality and comfort are great. They do tend to fit a narrower foot, so I'm not sure if they'd work for wider feet. This is a very classic penny loafer.

This is a beautiful shoe, but it runs small. I own many Pikolinos in 41, and this shoe felt narrow and short. I'd have tried a size up but it isn't available.