Customer Reviews ECCO Modtray Penny Loafer

The big white piece on the black loafer does not come off. I was very surprised. It looks totally out of place. I had to return it.

Unlike other reviewers, I found these to be too narrow, especially for ECCO! And what is up with the white tray tech billboard on the side? I was hoping it was removable..it's not. I returned them.

I'm usually a 6.5 or 7, so I ordered the 37 in this show. It's huge. I love the look of it, so I'm exchanging it for a 36. It's light for a lugsole, and the cognac color is very versatile.

I usually wear a 8 and the 7-7.5 is what fits so clearly these run large.

These are really nice looking and super comfortable. I have a lot of foot issues (falling arches, bunion, structural) and this is the first shoe I’ve found that doesn’t irritate them. Tremendous amount of support which is what I need. First pair of EECO I’ve tried and I’m a fan now!

I love the looks and quality of these shoes, sadly, they do not come in narrow and are just too wide for my long skinny feet. Why is it that wide is offered so many times, but seldom narrow? They must go back. Thanks Zapoos for your easy return policy.

Leather loafers have to be well-designed because there are no laces or elastic to hug them to your feet. Ordered my usual size 9.5 and the fit is very comfortable for my average-width foot. The arch support is moderate and feels quite good. I love the classic look of the brown loafer updated with the lug sole. Happy to have found these after trying on a lot of loafers that were too loose.

These were very attractive but juuuust a bit too big for me. I ordinarily wear a 7.5 and a 7 in Clarks; got them in 38 which is my normal euro size. Given the heavy lug heel I ultimately decided that heel pads wouldn't fix the issue. I love the style though and will try to find it in a smaller size.

I just received these. They are very lightweight. The leather is good quality. I have an Ecco Chelsea boot with the same footprint that is extremely comfortable. I want to point out that it runs large. I am normally a 8 1/2 to 9 narrow and I have bunions and hammer toes. All my Ecco shoes are 38. They are true to size when you compare them to each other, but not when you convert to American size. I am not crazy about the white piece. I will have to wear them a bit more to be sure they don’t rub on my ankles, but I think they will be a great versatile shoe.

Very comfortable right out of the box. I like the white piece. It makes the shoes look traditional and edgy at the same time.

Super comfortable and just enough support for my high arches. I wore them for 4 days straight at a conference with no regrets that they were the only shoes I packed.

Attractive and a good fit, except my heels slip up and out of the shoes with each step.

I have a narrow foot (6AA), & thought I could use the 5.5 Medium. Nope, too big everywhere. I might try to get the size 5 Medium. Also, I did not like the white strip on the bottom & side of the sole. It cannot be removed.

I liked these immediately and wore them the day after they arrived (so I can’t return them). They are comfortable except for being too loose, which seemed to become a problem the more I wear them. My heel slips out of the shoes when I walk. I’ve tried inserts to make the fit tighter and heel grips to help keep the shoes on but so far the things I’ve tried only help minimally. Disappointing in an expensive shoe.

Love the fit and comfort of these shoes. A little disappointed that you can’t put a penny in them and they are a little plain. However the cuter other pair I ordered does not feel as good. So I’m keeping these.

This was close to the correct size and cute. However, what you cannot easily see is a piece of white plastic attached at the middle of the heel on the outside of the shoe that curves around the edge and can be seen on the side (not hidden just on the sole. By any name this is a design error. If I could remove this chunk of white plastic. I would keep the shoe.

They were great except the sides are so high they are hitting my ankle bones - so sadly, they must go back......

This shoe was listed as size 4 & wasn't even close! Felt more like a 5-5.5. Overall the shoe seemed of great quality & loved the classic style but had to return - only 3 stars due to fit.

These shoes are perfect to dress up with office wear, or dress down with jeans. The color is unique in a great way. But, there are big issues for me. The heel is much too wide. My foot slips even with a heel slip pad; there is ZERO arch support; the toe box is as narrow as pumps; and the shoe gaps at the top of the foot area. Far too many misses in design for a shoe that carries this price tag.

Too narrow. Returned item

Nice looking shoe, just too snug on my foot.

Beautifuuly made shoe- Just the size was to small

Cute loafer and Ecco usually fits in a size 38. On this one, it was too large. Might fit a size 7 1/2, but not a size 7. Had to return.

For a leather loafer, these were instantly comfortable. I wore them around the house for a bit to "make sure" and then wore them the next day ALL day. LOVE them.

Good fit.