Customer Reviews Circus NY by Sam Edelman Deana

I have several pairs in this brand and these fit like the others. I loved the color. I didn't like that the metal embellishment on top was situated way toward the foot. I already am a size 10 and this made my feet look even more humungous than they already are! I couldn't really tell this detail from the photo. I kept them, though. Where else am I going to get a pair of pink loafers? LOL!

This shoe is a beautiful shoe and was true to size and felt great on my feet. I am so upset though because I really wanted to keep these shoes because they were exactly what I was looking for but the left shoe kept going up and down on my heel when I walked. The left heel was not as snug as the right heel. I hate this because they were so comfortable and I really really wanted to keep them but unfortunately I’ll have to return them. Maybe it was just this one pair. I may try another pair.

They were cute, but my heels kept sliding out, so it wasn't worth keeping them.

Super Cute, i love them! Hope to break them in a bit as they are snug.

I loved the shoe but the pink was a little brighter than the picture and I couldn't use them.

I ordered my regular 8.5 size for these shoes. The quality of them are great and their lining is soft and the fit is comfortable. I think these shoes are a great option for folks wanting a chunky loafer, however upon wearing them in-person, I realized this style wasn't for me.

Concerned it will develop creases. I got the tricolored ones. Absolutely stunning. But when just putting my foot in (with a little bit of force) it showed some creasing on the toebed. Thats without walking and moving in it. There are faint creases after taking the shoes off too. So I'm concerned at the long term creases. They do have crease guard adhesives for sneakers you can buy so i might try that although my feet are a bit wider so that might make less room for my feet... I'm keeping them of course lol. It will just require a bit more TLC than other shoes and will reserve for more special occasions or photo outfits lol. I was eyeing the JC tricolored ones for a while at like 3x the price. Saw these on sale and its a great dupe.

These shoes are cute but I can’t walk in them. They fit but every step I took my foot would come out of them at the heel. I am returning.

My daughter has an average side foot (not wide not really slim) these fit her comfortably. The buckle is really really cute too.

Terrific shoes. Very comfortable and stylish.

Well made durable and stylish! Excellent shoe for the office! Stylish and very comfortable!

Comfortable, Fit perfect, well made excellent quality and Classy

Stylish and true to size! great product and great price. I recommend!

Stylish and fit true to size! Great product and great price!!

Love the , looked better than expected . However, I am exchanging for a half size down. Auto recommend half size up...nope!

Love this shoe! It is very comfortable and a shoe that I can wear all day long!

This loafer is so comfortable! I wear a 6 1/2 and it's a perfect fit for me. I have a medium foot meaning not too wide and in-step not high. The inside of the loafer has a little cushion which is probably why this shoe is so comfy. The leather is soft and the bottom lug sole is not too much, just right! I love this loafer.