Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Waterproof XC4® Tanner Plain Toe

I've had these XC4 plain toe shoes for about three months and look forward to wearing them! These shoes are the most comfortable I've ever worn. I have plantar fasciitis and a low arch and have worn Ecco shoes for year which I also enjoy wearing....but these are by far the most comfortable shoe I've ever worn. They can be dressed up with slacks or more casual with dockers or jeans. They're very versatile and I've have had several people stop me in public and ask about them.

I wear no shoes other than JM for work. Comfortable and stylish!!!

Talk about cushion in a shoe that I can wear business casual. I'm enjoying these so far. Initially, the leather can feel a little stiff, but it's worth it. Overall great comfort in a nice looking shoe that can be dressed up or down.

This is my 4th pair of these shoes and I love them. I needed an all black pair which is why I bought these. I never have foot fatigue, even when I'm walking through the airport for 12 hours. I get compliments on these and highly recommend them.

The XC4 Tanner plain toe is my favorite J&M shoe. They are stylish, comfortable and chic. You can't go wrong.

This is my second pair. This shoes serve for me work, where I spend a lot of time walking outside on cement as well as dirt and grass. The waterproof feature has come in handy on more than a few occasions. The shoes are comfortable, durable, and long lasting (2 years for my first pair). I purchased both the black and the brown. I don't care for the cream side sole of the brown, but good shoes. Just what I was looking for at a reasonable price.

The XC4 Tanner Plain Toe is an amazing shoe in terms of the fit, comfort, style and the overall design. This is easily the best pair of shoes I've bought at Johnston & Murphy to date.

This is my 12th pair of J&M shoes, and I was looking for a more flexible shoe to wear, and less formal / business. I've worn with slacks and sports coat- but these would look great with jeans too. Great looking shoes and extremely comfortable. Would love a black suede shoe similar to this. I've gotten complements on them already. I'd recommend to anyone.

The most comfortable shoe I have ever worn, it is waterproof, and keeps its shine & looks without polish.

Great shoe, comfortable, looks great, and keeps its look without polish. Have had many compliments.

Most comfortable shoe everfor real! I can wear it all day on my feet at a trade show with no discomfort!

I rely on XC4 Tanner Plain Toe shoes for long walks in New York City. I own the Tan Full Grain size 9. They provide unmatched comfort and excellent support. They carry the style and comfort I need, making them perfect for both my daily work routine and long distances.

I love Tanner brogues. This is my third pair. Please keep making them. They are the best shoe I've found for balance and comfort and good style at the same time.

I finally broke down and bought pair #2 of these. My original pair lasted 4 years of pretty much daily wear for that 4 years. They were exceedingly comfortable and supportive, probably the most comfortable shoes I have ever owned. I cannot say enough good things about them, as they are stylish for my business casual workday (even can wear them with casual suits/sport coats), yet casual to wear with jeans. All day comfort for me. Very durable, as 4 years attests. Hopefully they'll be around in 4 more years when I need pair #3.

I bought these shoes for comfort as I do a lot of walking and standing. They are exactly what I needed and more.

I have 5 pairs of Johnston &Murphy dress shoes and just bought a pair for my son in law. He is on his feet all day and now wants the same pair in brown

The first day I wore the shoes to work, I had them on for 14 hours. They fit like a glove and comfortable all day long. I even received a compliment before I got in the office. Perfect combo, style and comfort.

All positives, no negatives.

2nd pair of these shoes. Travel quite a bit and these shoes have a dressy look but are good for walking around in the rain or wet conditions. Only negative criticism is that the bottoms can be a little slippery in wet smooth surfaces.

Feel Great! Look Great!

Best shoes on the market

These shows are super comfortable. They are nice-looking dress shoes, but far more comfortable than typical ones. They help me take brisk walks during short breaks at my workplace to get some steps and stay healthy despite my predominantly sedentary job. They have softer foam soles, and they fit very well.

I'm probably like a lot of men I wearing shoes like to work every day. I must admit, these are the most comfortable pair I've had for as long as I can remember. Well done J&M!