Customer Reviews The Original Muck Boot Company Muckster Ii Mid

I couldn’t love these boots more! We got a new puppy this year and I needed a boot to slip on quickly for potty training. My Uggs weren’t holding up to all weather conditions so I was specifically looking for something lined with warmth and comfort for multiple quick trips outside day and night. These check every box! I usually wear a size 8 or 8.5 and I sized up to a 9. I love the extra room for socks and general comfort. I would say you could size down if you like more of a snug feel. The size 9 doesn’t feel too big and they don’t slip off when I walk if you’re worried about that. They just feel roomier which I appreciate as I get older! These hold up to all weather conditions and keep my feet dry and warm. I’ve even been wearing them in the snow and my feet stay warm. They are my new favorite boot and I own several different top brands- Uggs, Sorels, Kamik, LL Bean, etc. The only downfall is that they don’t provide much traction in icy conditions. I slipped on my icy sidewalk after a winter storm. With rain and snow they are fine- but didn’t hold up to ice. But that could be said about lots of footwear I suppose.

I REALLY wanted to like these boots. I tried a 9 and walked right out of them (I normally buy a 9M). So I ordered an 8. It was still sloppy around the heel but the fit was better in the 8. It's a well made and cute boot. I work outdoors a lot and I wanted a step up in warmth from my go to Sloggers. However, when I wore them for some time, my left foot went numb. Yikes. The heel is too wide for my foot and the ball is too narrow. Sigh. Back to the drawing board.

These boots were purchased as barn boots. My feet get really cold really fast. I normally wear a 5-1/2 boot so ordered a 5 and a 6. The 6 was too big. The 5 fits comfortably with a thin sock, toe warmers and Acorn fleece socks. No break in required. They are very comfortable. My feet are still warm after 3 hours with temps in the low 20s. The sole seems slippery on ice, packed snow and smooth surfaces. These seem to be really warm, comfy and practical boots. And they don’t look too bad.

Looking for boots to slip on that are insulated for going out with dog or working in off season in the garden. I am usually a nine but these swam on me even with thick socks. Need to downsize to 8 but not available. Bummer. They seemed sturdy and well made and warm.

The fit is perfect, just the boots I needed for barn chores and warmth.

I needed a durable, easy on / easy off boot, suitable to wear in the muddy, freeeze/thaw conditions of winter turnout paddock at the stables. The Muck boots a great.

If you are looking for a fairly warm boot, these are not them. They are basically just a rain boot,

Was looking for a pair of boots to easily toss on. I have a very high arch so that’s a challenge. These do the trick.

love the boot, a little loose, but that's ok

My normal size is 8 1/2, I ordered size 8 and with socks they fit perfectly. A little on the roomy side without socks but that's fine because all I wanted were some boots that I could quickly slip on taking the dog out, yet be useful for working out in the yard. I tried 4 other boots that were either too clunky or too big/small before finally trying these (didn't really want to spend $100+ for boots that were just going to get messed up) and I thought Zappos was going to get mad at me for returning so many times! These Muck boots are perfect though. Comfy, easy on easy off, and not super heavy! Love these, highly recommend :)

I have a tall pair of Muck boots that I wore every day this winter walking my dogs, and they’re my usual size 10. I wanted to get the mid for spring and summer so I don’t wear the others out, but when I got the 10, it was too big. The 9 is perfect and immediately comfy! I can’t live without my muck boots! I’m like a little kid when there’s deep mud and puddles!

These boots are perfect to leave by the front door and slip on quickly for taking the dog out. They slide on/off easily and jeans slide into them and don't need to be adjusted. They don't pull off my socks when I take them off. They are comfortable with moderate but not great support. I love them for walking the dog but would wear boots with more support if I would be standing all day. They are warm and are a nice height to keep snow out while being easy to walk in. I have the plain black boots but would have preferred the plaid top, which was sold out in my size. They are easy to drive in. I am very happy with them!

I have an old pair of these in a size 8 which I have worn for years to walk the dog and to work in the yard. I normally wear a 8.5. Ordered a new pair and the new 8 is smaller than my old pair. I like to use an insert inside for extra comfort, and I don’t think there is room in the new pair. The old pair looks much wider than the new pair. I may have to return these. I have LOVED my old pair. I wear them every day in the yard. They are very comfortable boots, not that stylish, but great for everyday use in the yard.

It's not quite right for me. Going to try a different model. I have Muck Boots - Hoser but sadly they are not made any more.

I’m usually a 7 1/2 or 8. the 8 was too big and the 7 fit ok but the heels are way too loose and if I put on heavy socks the toes would be too tight. I want to love these as much as everyone else but they just don’t work for my feet.

They were fine but didn't feel as sturdy as the men's Muck boots I was replacing.

These are fake mucks. I called the company direct and they said Zappos is not an authorized dealer. REturning!

Is not available in half-sizes; instructions said to go up a size. I normally wear a size 7.5 shoe so I ordered this boot in size 8. The size 8 is huge! Can't imagine that a much smaller size would be ok either as this boot seems to be designed more for a man's foot.

Daughter purchased these Muck Boots Muckster Mid II in black, size 8. She wears 8.5 medium. They fit fine with thicker socks, and she plans to use them for gardening and for volunteering at a local farm. The boots claim to be 100% waterproof and mildly insulative. There is no pinching or pain if she jumps or crouches. The tops can be folded down, and jeans with either a tight fit to the calves or a wider bell at the bottom would suit these boots, but she could tuck in pants if necessary. I only wish the boots came in my size! Appreciate the sale price, too!

Fits great

These boots hit a homerun! I wear them everyday through water, mud, dirt and soon snow. No hands needed. I just slip my feet into the boots. I bought my true shoe size and even with a thick sock, I can still slip my feet in. I can't believe I waited so long to purchase these!

Rubber is soft enough to accommodate my extra-wide, flat feet. Very easy to slip on. Very pretty floral print liner. Very comfortable.

These are fleece lined. Very warm and comfortable, just not what I need in my mild climate.

I LOVE these. Absolutely necessary on my property. So many geese, so much poop. I can hose these clean! And they are comfy.

These boots are perfect for gardening! They are super flexible in the shaft which allows for easy movement all over the garden. Very easy to clean too. I’m a solid 7 1/2. The 7 1/2 I ordered fits well but I cannot wear them with thick socks. May want to size up depending on your fit preference.