Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Waterproof XC4® Maddox Penny

I was anticipating comfort like my XC4 shoes but found just the opposite in the two pairs sent to me. I have since returned them to you.

With they make more styles of these penny loafers. It's perfect!!!!!!

really disappointed to see this shoe being discontinued- one of the best shoes on the market!

I love these shoes. I live in Utah. When it's snowing or raining, I put these shoes on and not worry about the weather. They look great--classy for work, church, social gathering--I've had nice compliments. They're one of the few styles without the "hip" white soles. Very comfortable.

Thee most comfortable shoes I have.

Quick delivery. Very comfortable shoes.

Very pleasant experience with placing the order and receiving the shoes on a timely basis and was kept abreast of the timing of the delivery.

with the shrinking "slim" "tailored" fits in clothes, shoes seem to be on the same path. Not J&M no way. Shoes actually fit, and was on my feet 4 hours through 2 church services.... no break in required. Awesome shoes.

Good on all counts.

Well made and Fit great, very comfortable.loved the color. Will buy again.

It's rare to be able to slip on a new shoe and wear it comfortably from the start all day, but that's what happens for me with Maddox Penny loafers. For a comfort shoe, the styling is appropriate for both casual or more dressed up occasions. The padded heal and sole are easy on my back and the price is easy on the budget. The fact they are also waterproof also makes them an excellent choice for travel wear. In my opinion, this is the best all-round shoe to have.

Husband loves this shoe! Has bought same shoe many times. Very durable and lasts a long time but he puts a lot of miles on his shoes. Wears them with dress pants nice shirts and tie.

Love the shoes but are a little tight and narrow, even after removing liner, would have preferred not to have to remove liner.

Good fit

I love your shoes

Stylish and comfy!

Looks great and very comfortable!

Excellent craftsmanship

Very nice shoe, excellent craftsmanship Excellent customer service,

nice shoes. love the waterproof feature

The most comfortable Johnson & Murphy of all I have had.

really like the shoe. I wear 10's in everything - occasionally 10 1/2s. I ordered 10's in these and they are a 1/2 size too big. Should have ordered 9 1/2's. I wore them for a while and realized it was just a mistake.

Heal could of been better built. Now when are we going to see an xc4 Cody Cap toe?

Good shows but a little lacking on the style side. Very comfortable.