Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Cody Plain Toe Shearling Boot

By far, the most comfortable casual sneaker type shoe that I have ever tried. Absolutely fantastic....loved them so much, I bought a second pair!

These great looking shoes are really comfortable and stylish. I get compliments on them every time I wear them.

Great, quality shoe. They fit great and comfortable all day. Stylish to wear with anything and anywhere.

The shoes fit true to size and are comfortable. A few things to know: the Shearling lining does not cover the entire upper : the bottom 1-1/2 inch or so is unlined, as is the entire forefoot (not including the tongue, which is lined). I bought these for winter wear, and just wore them for the first time after a snowfall. The sole is not as soft ("rubbery") as it should be, and while flexible, is actually quite slick on packed snow, polished stairs and parking lot ice - not quite leather slippery, but easy the worst traction of the soles of three dressier lined boots I own (mephisto, brunomagli and these). I can get over the partial shearling lining, but the sole should be a softer material to minimize slipping. These are good indoor boots (as many others are), but that is not why i purchased the them.

Love JM shoes and that is all I wear. I bought these and loved how they fit and how they breathed. Downside was that on the 4th time I wore them, the color on the rubber in the front of the show started wearing off. This is a design flaw. It's horrible because I really love the way the shoe fits, which is why I gave it 3 stars despite of the flaw. I wish I could post a photo.

The feel and fit perfectly, but after one time wearing them the front of the shoe was scraped and turned from black to white.

This was my 5th J & M shoe purchase & by far the most disappointing. The shoe itself is comfy, stylish, and breathable. Unfortunately the black rubber trim around the top has a thin black coating and is not the same color beneath. After some use, it gives the appearance of being scuffed or streaked with white paint. For the price of these shoes, I'd expect more quality in design.

Perfect

These boots are great! Super comfortable and versatile. Can be worn with jeans or a suit. Beautifully made.

Good quality shoe with style and function.

My husband really likes these boots. They are very comfortable and warm for the winter. Fit true to size, he wears a 10 in boots. He only wears Johnston and Murphy, they are well made, very comfortable and durable. Definitely would recommend.

Very comfortable and stylish , like many JM shoes I've purchased over the years!

I loved the elegance and the fit of this boot. I almost did not want to wear it but look at it unused. But is extremely comfortable.

Got them in brown and black ! fits great looks amazing

Very quality product I am very happy with these boots I highly recommend the comfort and the quality

These boots are very stylish and very comfortable. I really like theat can wear them with jeans or dress pants. I will get a lot of use out of them. I've been wearing Johnston and Murphy for about 40 years, they are my favorite dress shoes.

Awesome boot, great fit and super comfy.

I love them they're very comfortable and they protect me from the cold weather and they look very elegant the quality is very fine

Super comfortable, stylish. Get all my footwear from JM, last 2 pairs of boots lasted a decade!

Fit great, break in quickly, good traction on European stone sidewalks.

Very nice style . Good blend of dressy and rugged . I am a size 13 ,it fit nicely with a warm sock .

run a little small

These shoes are so comfortable and good looking. They seem as if they will last forever. As tough as boots!!

Very happy with these boots. Comfortable right out of the box.

Definitely a quality product all the way around. Leather calibre is excellent, the lush color allows this boot to be a very dressed up or just very classy casual. Comfortable and supportive footbed. Very happy with this purchase particularly with Black Friday sale price.