Customer Reviews Altra Superior 4.5

This Superior 4.5 has very similar attributes to my last pair of Superior Altra shoes but it is more narrow and smaller than my last pair which is very disappointing because the whole reason I loved this brand and style was the fact that it was a shoe that was wide and allowed enough space for my toes to spread out. Another complaint is that Altra changes the fit of their shoes even if it is the same style from year to year or every two years. The consistency of their product is just not there. I thought I found a brand that I could stick with but I think this is the last time I'll buy from this

I've been a big fan of Altra Superior running shoes, but these did not meet my expectations. The best feature of Superior's is the large toe box. My 4.0s were great, but they were wearing out so I bought 4.5s. Unfortunately, they did not have the same feel at all and the toe box was tight. I hope the next generation brings back the roomy toe box.

Really mixed feelings on this shoe, most of which may be chalked up to my foot type. I have a narrow, medium arch, morton's toe (longer second toe, really feels more like shorter big toe to me). 1. Because of dramatic toe box curve back towards outside of foot, I had to go up 1.5 sizes (normal 11, Altra 12.5) to keep toes 2-5 from hitting rubber toe bumper. That's a lot, but I don't feel like the shoe is too long (no tripping on things for example). Just a heads up if you have longer toes 2-5. 2. Soft (lack of) heel cup, flat insole surface and very slick synthetic upper material allows almost entire foot to rotate inside of shoe at walking speed over uneven terrain. I ended up putting a 3/8 met pad on a thin insole under the Altra insole and that gave enough contour to hold my foot in position inside the shoe but they still feel like they have too much leverage side to side over uneven surfaces at walking speeds somehow. 3. Sole very slick when wet on hard surfaces ie rocks, roots and pavement. Scary slick. Protruding trapezoids on sides of soles collect and hold on to mud very effectively. All that said : these are amazing to run trails in. Love the lacing system and laces, love the dynamic feel of the shoe, love the (dry) grip of the tread, love the breathability, toe bumper is an excellent mix of flexible yet effective, conforming heel and midfoot with wide toebox, high quality materials and construction. I don't recommend for wet climates because of the slippery when wet behavior of the soles. But you can really hang it out with these on dry trails! I also don't recommend these as walking/hiking shoes, as mentioned above I don't really understand why but I feel unstable in these at walking speed. I was hoping these would be a better all around shoe but they are so good as a trail runner that I am going to try a few other styles from Altra (walker and hiker) to see how they go.

Great looking shoe and very comfortable. Bought for son, landscape architect, on his feet alot. He loves them!

While they are listed as a medium width they run true to the Altra form of having a wider toe box which is why I bought these, even though they are listed as medium width. This is my fourth pair of Altra (Escalante's previous 3 times) and enjoy the fit and feel of these shoes.

I wear these when I need a shoe that is light as a feather and fits like a second skin. I cant imagine wearing socks with these, so if you’re the type to pull your white tube socks to your knees, keep shopping.

I loathe to call these "budget" but these perform better than kicks costing $30, $40 or even $50 more. I had never heard of this brand and usually sport On, inov8 or Topo but these kicks may have just moved to the to top of the list.

I really like this shoe a lot would recommend them.

I’ve grown to love these shoes. At first I thought it was weird that the tongue is attached on one side but it doesn’t bother me after wearing these for a while. And they’re really comfortable

Running personality shoes.!!!

Amazing shoes. Very comfortable. Wide toe box.

I love Altras and this style is the best....color and fit perfectly and just right for my orthotics, too.

Altra comes through again. Solid shoe my son wears every day to school and runs cross country in.

I normally wear size 14 but always go up to 15 with Altras. This shoe fits the same as the others. Good fit, comfortable, nice shoe.

Feet have hurt for years …these shoes are perfect for my many trips up and down the stairs

Good fit, true to size, good looking. A wonderful shoe.

first pair of trail shoes I have ever owned. feel really good and my trail runs have been more enjoyable by me not slipping and sliding around as much.

Had the 3.5s before and like this one as well. It complements the Lone Peaks well. Lighter with less stack but still cushy and comfy. Great trail shoe! Would buy again.