Customer Reviews Propet Feya

These were a welcome find! I have very hard to fit feet. They're super wide, high arches with thick ankles. I have returned so many shoes I've lost count. These were just the right fit for me. I wore them all day right out of the box with no issues at all. (This NEVER happens for me!) I take a size 8 WW in Easy Spirit (which always fit), and that's the size for these that worked just right. I tried a 7.5 WW too because in the past Propet has run large for me. The 7.5 pair were fine for length, but they were just a tad too tight in the width and I knew it would bother me later. So if you've got puffy Fred Flintstone feet with high arches like me, these should do the trick for you!

Loved the way these shoes looked and fit! Nice to have an open toe shoe that has a little more foot covering than the standard sandal.

These are really cute sandals, which is hard to find when you have Fred Flintstone feet and ankles. They width was perfect. The strap was a little high for swollen ankles, but doable. The downside is that the box arrived with mis-matched shoe sizes; an 8 and a 7.5. I requested an exchange due to this problem and the replacement pair was also mis-matched in size. Luckily I still had the original pair with the opposite sizes for the feet and was able to swap them out and end up with a properly sized pair of sandals. How this mix up happened is beyond me. Zappos really needs to work on that quality control thing.

I love these sandals. I have very wide feet- a 7.5EEE, and usually have to go up to an 8 or 8.5 to get shoes wide enough to fit. The 7.5EEEE fit comfortably right out of the box! It’s so hard to find sandals that fit, so I’m very happy. And these look nice with pants, skirts and shorts.

The size was perfect 8WW but as you walked, the arch of the foot against the shoe created a suction that resulted in a “fart” sound...not appropriate. Due to this, I had to send them back.

Cute shoes but my foot slipped forward when trying them out and the toes ended up far too close to the front of the shoe. It may be the angle of the shoe or maybe how I walk, but sorry, must send them back.

Such a beautiful shoe in every way. But I knew when I opened the box and saw XX (4E) that this wasn't going to fit. Doesn't even come close to being a 4E (I have narrower width shoes that fit perfectly) Propet is my go to brand and usually have little to no problems. Very sadly I must return.

These are super cute but I found them to be very uncomfortable. They were a snug fit (but not too tight), but they felt like they were pinching the sides of my feet every time I took a step. I couldn’t figure out why.. I can only come up with that it is possibly because they are so stiff and don’t bend with my foot when I walk.

I really want to love these sandals, esp. since my spouse thinks they look really cute on me, and they do have lovely arch support. Perhaps one 1/2 size up would make a difference or if I keep wearing them to get the leather to stretch a bit more. These are supposed to fix a 4E? Not quite. My right foot is a 3E, left 2E and both left and right are still too narrow, both as my foot goes into the main part of the sandal and the footbed in general. They do what so many sandals I've tried do - bow slightly where the leather can't lay down flat, because it's being stretch beyond its capacity. Sigh. I'm going to give them over the weekend, but I'm afraid these may have to go back.

Very pretty shading on this leather and it fits well - happy with this shoe!

Great stiff sole sandal. cute and comfy.

Love the sandals. I wear 7.5 W because one foot swells during the day. This sandal looks good whether you're dressed up or down.

I wear a 7.5 W this fit perfectly.

Because the fit is a little bit bigger overall, the shoes are not quite right on my feet. They look great, but aren’t “all day” comfortable.

Based on some of the reviews saying these sandals ran small, I ordered one size up and had to exchange for my normal size which is 10 4E. I really like the sandal and look forward to wearing them!

These sandals were just what I was looking for in a 4 extra wide, but I couldn't get my foot in far enough to fasten the strap. So disappointed!

I am really sad that I have to return these. I can get my foot into them, but it hangs off of the side because the shape of this sole is not wide enough.

the 2E was not wide enough for the ball of my foot.