Customer Reviews Madewell Sidewalk Low Top Sneakers

Love these! They look great on and will go with everything. Truly a timeless shoe for all seasons. Great quality leather and super comfy. I'll be exchanging for a 1/2 size bigger, as they run a tad small. But in my experience, all Madewell shoes run about a 1/2 size too small - I should have assumed! :) Pleased with my purchase.

Love these!! Ordered half size up as suggested by other reviewers. Excellent quality, comfortable shoe. The removable insole seemed good but I replaced for my orthotics.

oh my gosh. at least a full size too small. so cute, so will reorder.

Size and fit are true. Very comfortable foot bed but no arch support. There is enough room inside so I could add an arch support insert in the future if I need. I love the look of these. So cute and they can go with business casual or jeans. Love love love them. If you have sensitive heels, it helps to wear the no show nude liners with the silicone heel.

Super comfy, love the colors in person. Great shoes

I saw these shoes on sale in Madewell store but they didn't have my size so bought them here for the same price. They fit well and have broken in easily. Most sneakers make my feet look big (they ARE big, size 10, lol) but these don't do that. Love them.

I expected these shoes to have a cute rainbow, to be cute pride sneakers. But the rainbow isn’t a full spectrum rainbow but instead just a a few colors, muted and subtle. I kept them but they aren’t proud.

I went up half a size to comfortably accommodate socks and arch support insert.

These are the MOST COMFORTABLE 'casual white sneakers' you can buy - believe me, I tried so many. I could wear these all day walking/on my feet and they feel - and look - great! I bought more than one pair, I love them that much!

These ran a half size bigger on me. They are really cute and are of great quality. I haven’t worn them out yet, but can tell the heel sits a little higher and rubs against it when I walk.

I love these sneakers! Very comfortable & they fit true to size. I’m able to wear them all day at work without my feet hurting

Took a few walks to break in but all in all this is a great shoe!

Love these sneaks, got many compliments. They are very cushioned on the bottom but I did get some blistering from the back rubbing a bit. It won’t prevent me from wearing them though.

Love the shoes! True fit.

I really liked look & feel of these shoes but they were too big. I ordered a size 9 but need a 8.5 or 8. I liked the canvas material and think they would wash up great!

Fit is true to size. Very comfortable insole compared to others I've tried.

I've never tried a pair of Madewell before and was impressed with how comfortable they were. The interior was quite cushy, and the medium footbed fit my slightly broad foot okay. I wound up going with a different pair of tennis shoes because I liked their style better, but can definitely recommend these as a good choice.

I’m not quite sure why everyone said to size up. I received my usual size 7 and they were big enough for my heel to slip out the back every time I took a step. Sadly will be returning. I wish there was a 6.5 in stock because I would definitely purchase as the style is super cute!

These shoes are so cool and just ehat I was looking for. The only problem is they’re stiff and kind of heavy. I wanted to keep them but I’m not into uncomfortable shoes just for the look.

These shoes were way too wide for me feet my heel kept slipping out of them even with super thick socks on. These shoes were a definite no go for me. The soles of the shoes also felt very stiff.

These are bad quality shoes. Got it several days ago and the rubber bottom is already falling apart. Don’t recommend.

Not good at all, received several days ago and the rubber bottom already start to falling apart. Don’t recommend

These are super cute and were comfortable when I first tried them on. Seem like good quality even though arch support is lacking. But after wearing for just a couple of hours (in an airport, mostly sitting) it became clear these are in fact the worst sneakers I’ve ever had the misfortune to purchase. I don’t know what is up with the back heel but they IMMEDIATELY began to rub. There is no doubt they are the correct size for me, and I’ve never had this problem with sneakers whether purchased through Zappos or elsewhere. Now I’m left with a brand new, bloodstained pair of shoes. Will not purchase Madewell brand again.