Customer Reviews Steve Madden Georgette Over the Knee Boot

OMG! All of my ladies with slim legs - you need these! I have SUPER skinny legs and these boots actually fit! I don't know how anyone with regular/larger legs could possibly squeeze into these but if you are looking for a pair that will stay up for skinny legs - these are it!

I’ve been looking for the perfect OTK Block heel boot for a few years. Each fall/winter I’ve tried several styles at different price points and there was always something wrong with each pair (large circumference for my thinn calves, thigh high instead of OTK, leather looked too shiny, too pointy, stiff & uncomfortable) until I found these. I’ve not worn them yet but when I tried them on they felt so comfortable and hit right above the knee (I’m 5’4”). They hug my legs but have enough stretch to wear them with leggings and jeggjngs underneath. They also have a silicone strip around the top to keep them from slipping when worn with dresses or skirts (although IDK yet how effective that’ll be but they feel amazing!) My only complaint is that they don’t come in a leather option, only suede. My perfect boot would’ve been leather but these will be great. They’re amazing!!! Sexy, yet classy and versatile.

These were so cute and I was so excited to get them, but unfortunately they felt unusually narrow for my feet. That’s quite uncommon for me because I’m a size 5 and have very narrow feet as it is! Even in regular socks, after struggling to get them on, it just felt incredibly uncomfortable to walk in. I’m usually happy with Steve Madden but maybe these boots’ width just runs smaller than usual. I can’t speak on the quality of them since I only got to try them on, but I love the style and they fit my calf area nicely instead of slipping down which is what a lot of knee high boots tend to do.

I am 5’1” and petite with small legs. The boots fit me very well. So far they seem to stay up on me even without jeans. The material is soft and somewhat stretchy so I assume they will work over leggings/skinny jeans too. They’re very comfortable! Overall happy with my purchase.

Great shoe except the zip at the back is in an awkward position which makes the shoe look less cute from the side, and also the zip can sometimes cut into your skin. Not an issue if worn over jeans, but slightly annoying if you're just wearing tights. Shoe doesn't always stay up above the knee after walking for a while. Otherwise, the heel is a good height, walkable but also not too flat.

Ugh, I hate to send these back! I've been searching for the last two winters for over the knee boots that fit my narrow calves, and don't hit at a weird spot on my knees. I tried these on and they were perfect: true to size, fit to my calves beautifully, and were fairly comfortable. Unfortunately one reason I bought these is that the description said the uppers were made of leather; the stamp on the inside of the upper however, shows they're all fabric and synthetic materials. They don't feel like they'll last more than a season and definitely won't hold up to much damp weather here in the PNW. Obviously if this isn't an issue to you or you're on the search for vegan boots, go for it! One other minor complaint is the soles don't have any grip so they are slippery. Overall they're super cute and sexy, just not 100% what I was looking for.

I have heavy calves and almost never find tall boots that have enough stretch. These are PERFECT, and what a great look with long slit skirts and tight leggings. Love them!!

I always have such a hard time finding boots that aren’t huge around my ankles and these are perfect! They are a little snug at the top but I’m sure they will stretch out. If you have skinny legs/ankles, these boots are perfect for you!

For the price, I don’t know how these boots are even in stock. Are they the most high quality material? No. But are the sexy, leg lengthening and affordable? YES! This is my first season buying over the knee boots and didn’t want to go all out in case I didn’t wear them all that much. I bought these in black and brown. They both look amazing and can’t wait to wear them with dresses and skirts all winter and stay warm(er). For the commenters saying the toe box was narrow- make sure you remove ALL the packing material. The first one I put on, I took out the tissue paper but didn’t remove the cardboard crease protector in the toe box. It took me to the second boot to realize what the problem was! These boots are fire! A definite buy!

normally a 6 or 6 1/2 and had to get a 7. Love these boots.

These boots are so beautiful and such great quality. I love how they fit my skinny legs!! I weigh around 100 lbs and they are slightly, tiny bit baggy but with jeans they are great! I am 5’2 and they hit right above me knees, around an inch or 1.5 inches above which i love. I can’t wait to wear these :))). I would say they run true to size, i got a 6.5 and there is a bit of room in case i would like to wear thick socks with them. The are a bit narrower than other boots i own but fortunately i have slim feet so its not an issue for me, if you have wider feet they may be a little harder ti fit in and might hurt. Overall, i suggest you Buy them ! you’ll feel like a bad b i promise lol.

Wish I could've kept these since I thought they were pretty comfortable. However, the listed shaft height isn't measured correctly. It's 22.5 inches from the BASE of the heel up to the top of the boot, so if you have long calves like me it will barely cover your knee. I have concerns also that it would slouch a bit over time.

Beautiful boots but definitely not for taller women or anyone without pencil thin legs. I bought these hoping to replace a pair of over the knee boots that I loved and wore constantly. These will only fit over tights or bare legs and cannot be worn with pants because they are too tight around calf. I am tall and thin and have never had an issue with boots around my calf. The height of them at least on me was also not so much “over the knee” as right AT the knee. I am 5’9 for reference. Definitely a nice design but just didn’t work for my dimensions or purposes. Unfortunately I bought these without. Return option so I will be trying to get use out of them with dresses and skirts but they will not work for me for my intended purpose.

Good quality boots. The boots fit the best with a legging and does not go over jeans. I wish it did. Lovely color though.

Loved these! Bought several different pairs and these were my favorite. Comfortable and cute. One thing to note is that the zipper is on the back. It makes the profile of the boot look really nice, but can be somewhat troublesome to zip up.

I am a size 10 but usually find closed toe, size 10 Steve Madden shoes a bit short. The size 10 in this boot was ok, but I wondered if my toes would really start to feel the end after standing or walking in them for 2-3 hours. Otherwise, best bang for the buck! I have ordered at least 6 pairs of boots that were a lot more expensive because I wanted a pair of dress boots - to wear with dresses - that either really went all the way to my knees (which most don't) or over the knee. Even though these are synthetic stretch suede, they look fantastic and will probably wear better than real suede. And they are easy to put on and take off - which is not true for many over the knee boots.

It’s so hard to find the perfect boot. Really happy with my purchase because finally I found one that was perfect I would hug my leg not too tight or loose. I thank all of those who have submitted reviews

Some of the comfiest shoes I’ve ever tried on. My only complaint is that they’re a smidge wide at the top. I could have easily work over jeans/leggings and they would’ve stayed up.

I have skinny calves and finding boots that aren't too wide and not sag has been an issue. These boots fit great all over. Comfortable heel height. No complaints.

Beautiful shoes!! Received many complements! I felt that the shoes were a little tight and narrow, but loved them regardless.

If you have skinny legs this is a must-buy. I have tried dozens and dozens of boots (including stuart weitzmann) and none of them fit as well as these do. Most manufacturers produce boots with too much material (leather or suede) around the ankle area. This creates a wrinkling or scrunch of the material every step you take and is super unflattering. I've experienced so much frustration buying expensive boots that just looked so bad on me. These have just the right amount of material and fit perfectly around my ankles. These are comfortable and reasonably priced. The quality isn't amazing; they seem like they may not be that warm in the winter. But this can be fixed with leggings and/or warm socks. A gorgeous silhouette, you will not regret!

The calf of the boot fits very snug, which i don't mind because its hard to find narrow calf boots to fit my skinny legs. However, the overall quality is very poor. Poor material (poor quality fake suede material). It looks very cheap and I wouldn't wear these out unless i'm wearing it as part of a costume

I wore these all day at an outdoor event, walking over 10,000 steps over the river and through the woods…..my feet felt fantastic! I have small bunions and they didn’t bother them at all. Highly recommend!

The fit was great!

It was a great fit. Except my legs are too skinny to hold them up. I have to wear a pair of knit leg warmers inside the boot to keep them up in place. KB