Customer Reviews Blue by Betsey Johnson Paige Pump

I ordered this shoe for an outside, black tie event in Colorado. The block heel was perfect for walking in grassy area. The shoe runs short. Because of the pointy toe it begins to narrow quickly. Go up at least half a size.

Loved the look of these shoes, but they were very uncomfortable. Chunky heel felt like it was pushing my toes forward as a I walked, squishing them into the toe box. I have a narrow foot and the fit was good, heel didn't slip, but these were so painful to walk in (and I'm used to walking in heels). Purchased for a gala, but there was definitely no dancing to be had in them.

Beautiful shoe, VERY POINTY toe! Runs small, need full size larger.

Wanted to love them, but once on, the heel kept slipping off, but the toe room even when I forced by foot back was not great. It was ok, but then with an orthotic in it I could have made them work, but once on I just didn’t like the look. The stunning heel just felt overpowering and disconnected. Still a quality shoe, but then when I noticed the significant toe cleavage I was done and sent them back. I love bold fashion in my shoes, but these just didn’t flick my switch as I thought they would. Oh the gen’s are attached well, but still came with some extra loose stones in a baggie incase you lost any. I like that touch.

These are absolutely perfect! When I saw them online, I knew I had to order them for my wedding next year. Yes, I said next year...as in 2021! I was afraid these beauties would be gone, so I ordered them immediately. I normally wear a size 7 in heels, and these fit perfectly. I would say that if your foot was super narrow, these shoes might be loose through the toe and heel.

Beautiful shoes.I wanted to keep them. I tried an 8.5 and a 9 and both were pinching around the toe area.

I love these shoes. I needed a half size larger.

Gorgeous shoes. The heels are the star. Very unique. Glad I read the other reviews and got 1/2 size larger than my usual size. Perfect!

They are super comfortable. Other reviewers noted the toe bed is narrow. I didn’t find that to be a problem at all. Love them!!

Love these shoes! The heel is fantastic and the shoes are surprisingly comfortable.

Stiff shoe, but gorgeous for a wedding and wearable all night with the block heel. Ordered the 7, I'm a 6.5/7, and needed a little pad in the heel to keep it from slipping. They look like an absolute disco ball. Perfect.

I have a wider foot, and I’ve tried Betsy Johnson in the past and they’ve been to narrow. With a “wide” shoe I am an 8, so I sized up to a 8.5 and they are perfect! They don’t slip off my heel but our wide enough at the toe. The rhinestone don’t look cheap, pictures can’t do the sparkle justice. Great heel height for all day, I’m excited for the world to open up again so these can get more wear than around my house ?

These shoes are amazing. They just came 1 day too late for a wedding. I love zappos, I usually get them the next day, but it was the week before Christmas.

Size 6 fit perfectly. These are such happy shoes. Added just the right bling to floor length ruched black dress purchased in France. Being short I appreciate good heels. These hit all the right notes: pretty, festive, comfortable, and the heel provides both elevation and support.

Beautiful shoes, thought toe was more rounded

I really wanted to love these shoes but unfortunately the sizing is just very strange/off. For reference, I have a narrow foot and normally wear a size 8.5. The first time I ordered these shoes I went with an 8.5. My toes were super tight at the tops of the shoes and thus I decided to exchange them for a 9. The 9's were too big... My foot kept sliding forward, causing a large gap at the heel. It made it difficult to walk. The sides of the shoes also rubbed on the sides of my feet, it was pretty uncomfortable. I think a little wear might resolve this issue but obviously, I returned the shoes before I could test that out. Also, this didn't bother me too too much but the way the shoe fits, the tops of the toes show in the show (in other words, your toes are not completely covered by the shoe). A little awkward in my opinion. Really wish these would have fit as the heel height and width were great for a supportive heel. The shoes also came with a baggie of extra rhinestones (in case any were to fall off) which was nice.

These shoes are just beautiful! Elegant with just the right amount of sparkle. And in spite of the pointy toe box, they were not uncomfortable. I’m not sure that I would want to stand on my feet in them all day, but they are special occasion shoes after all. I wore them for a few hours at a Christmas party and my feet did fine in them. I highly recommend them for the sexiness aspect alone.

Beautiful shoe. But, it runs a bit big so I had to return it for it kept slipping off.

Gorgeous shoe. Heel is not too high. I am adding some extra padding for the ball of my foot and around the inside of the heel area. So looking forward to wearing these to my daughter’s wedding. The sparkle will be perfect with my dress.

Absolutely stunning shoe. The sparkle is top notch. The heel is the perfect height. Just a little too small for me in the toes so I had to return. If you have a wider foot size up. Unfortunately only goes up to an 11 so I’m out of luck ?

slightly big for a size 7. I have one foot larger than the other, but not to the extent that the shoe would slip off of the smaller foot. This one did. However, the shoes are stunning and fun! Dresses up a plain black dress or pant suit

With the pointy toe, I went up 1/2 size and while they were a little roomy, I don't think I could comfortably go with anything smaller. I added a heel grip and the shoe works just fine. They are super cute. Stylish with a bit of a flare. Got lots of compliments on them.

I really loved the style of this shoe. Perfect for the Holidays. But the fit was so bad. Too cramped in the toes and too loose in the heel area. I was so sorry to have to return them. I didn't even think I could make it through one night wearing them.

Beautiful shoe but the hill is much too high