Customer Reviews The North Face Shellista IV Tall

I wear a 7.5 or an 8, depending on the shoe. It took four tries to get the right size in these. 7.5 was TIGHT! 8 was TIGHT. 8.5 ... was it the right size? I wasn't sure, so I got a 9 as well to test it out. Only then was I sure that the 8.5 was the right size. But I never would have gone to all the trouble if there wasn't something wonderfully, satisfyingly intriguing about the boot. They're great looking but they're quite expensive. They're really tall - as another reviewer wrote, they're almost too tall if you're on the short side -- but if I didn't want full coverage, then I wouldn't be looking at tall boots. Having now taken the plunge, removed the extra set of laces and worn them outside (in the woods and for shopping), I'm delighted to report that I'm really happy with the purchase. They're very comfortable. They tie up nice and snug so that with leggings, I don't expect snow to so easily fall down inside the way snow always did with my high muck boots when I go snowshoeing. I've had no trouble with pants (jeans and other pants) going over them, I disagree with another reviewer on that score. My only two critical comments -- For shoppers: These are tall and stiff boots, which if why I like them, but it requires one to flex one's calf to get them off and at least once, I got a bit of a calf charlie horse. If your mobility is limited, that could be a problem. For the manufacturer: the laces are WAY WAY WAY too long and that's a real pain. The laces obviously need to be long to work in a boot like this, and the laces are distinctive so you can't replace them easily without mucking up the styling of them, but when they're laced up snuggly, there's between 16-18" of extra lacing at the top. I already had this snag on branches because even double tied, it flops around. Yesterday, I tied it around the back but that's not ideal.

These boots are almost comically tall on my short (I'm 5'4") legs and kind of make them look "chubby" as they have to go over my pants (no way you could fit these under your pants) but are very comfortable and warm (I'm in MN, so warmth is my #1 concern). I ordered in a 9.5 which is 1/2 size larger than my normal shoe size but I'm going to exchange them for 10's. I can tell just from walking around in them in my home that they are going to be very warm and keep out the wind/snow/water.

I was very pleased with these. Normally I wear Sorel, but find them heavy. These are light and very well made. Perfect for northern Wisconsin.

For the multiple inch snowfalls and extreme cold we get here on a weekly basis in Minnesota, I was looking for a boot that protected me from the elements. This fit the bill! I tested these in snow that drifted a foot high and temps down to -6, my legs and feet stayed warm and dry. Daily walks in warmer (10 degree) weather were also comfortable, no need to break these boots in at all. The only issue is getting them on and off can be a challenge, but in exchange for the comfort and cuteness level, I'll take it!

These boots are not only warm but also quite stylish! Don't be afraid of the red laces - the boots also come with gray laces, I've attached a picture here. Wide-calved ladies - these boots will fit! I have very muscular calves and it's hard to fit boots, but thanks to the lacing these work great. And, they're relatively easy to slip on and off too, which is hard to find in tall boots. It hasn't snowed here yet, so I can't review how effective they are in the snow, but I got quite warm wearing them in the house and they seem very well-constructed. They are a tad heavy, but that's to be expected in serious snow boots, and they're lighter than other boots I was considering, especially Sorels. They feel comfortable right out of the box. I bought these for heavy-duty weather and the Shellista II Roll-Down for everyday winter use, very pleased with both. I usually wear a 9.5, bought the size 10, and they fit great with or without thick socks.

These are the best boots I’ve ever had! As seen in other reviews, I ordered a half-size larger because I have bunions. Perfectly comfortable, so warm. I live in upstate NY and we often get more than a foot of snow. These boots are up to my knees. With laces, I should be able to keep snow out. And they were delivered in the mail in 5 days!

I am normally a nine in a shoe size. I noticed the reviews talking about go up 1/2 a size. Since I have a daughter who had a pair similar in North Face I went up a whole size and glad that I did. I am planning to wear these for everyday running errands in the snow and slop. These boots are a bit stiff and I hope they loosen up a bit with wearing them. They are not meant for extreme cold. They are not meant to wear heavy socks. If you have wide feet, these boots are very narrow. I do like them and think they will fit the need for everyday out and about.

I am consistently a size 7.5. Never order up. I got these in 8 because I tried on my friend’s boots and her’s were 8, and I liked them. They keep my legs nice and warm trudging in the snow. The red laces give them some style. Very comfortable and easy to get on. I might slog around town in them, but I ended up buying a shorter bootie for outfits. Great to throw over some leggings and walk the dog in the snow. Obviously in the photos you can see I’m trying to decide between two boots. I couldn’t decide, so I kept both. ??

Just what I was looking for. Wool and leather and waterproof and very warm. I wanted something I could walk in winter in Michigan while stay dry. These are easy to get on and also very cute. They do run small. I am normally a 9 or 9.5 and I got the 10’s. Luckily they are warm because thick socks would be too tight.

It fit perfect. Totally massive for all my snow activities. I'm amazedI'm a first time user and I'll use you guys again. The best toughest most waterproof stylish for snow

The fit was small. I usually wear size 10 but I went up to a 10.5. I thought the fit of 10.5 was perfect! I love these boots! I tried two other more expensive brands, but I couldn’t get past how comfortable and warm these boots are. I returned the others and kept these! I love how tall these boots are. I also love how warm they are! They didn’t need any break-in period. They were very comfortable from the first time I put them on. They are easy to get on and off with the laces loosened. The ankle is a bit loose but 8 believe that’s why they are eas6 to get on and off. These are lightweight too. I live in northern Illinois and walk my dogs 4 times a day. These are the perfect boot for me! They are warm, and waterproof, and comfortable. I hope they last a very long time because these are quickly becoming my favorite winter boots!