Customer Reviews Frye Carson Shootie

These are a beautiful all leather and suede shootie. The neutral color is very close to what I saw on my monitor and a color that I find very versatile. I bought my usual Frye size and the shoes fit as expected. Frye can be tight in the forefoot, but the slightly rounded toe of this shoe is comfortable for my B/C forefoot. The heels don’t slip on my slightly narrow heels. If you plan to wear this shoe with a thick or heavy sock you might want to size up.

I had a pair of Frye Carson pull-on (mid-calf) boots years ago that I LOVED, so I took a chance on these in the same size (9.5) even though I usually wear a 10 in most other brands. Maybe my feet have grown, or maybe I'm just fussier now, but they were too small. The toebox also seemed cramped in general--but then again, I mostly wear Dansko clogs, Doc Martens, and other "comfort" shoes nowadays (gotta love a roomy toebox!). If you have narrow feet, these could work for you! Just not me.

I have been on a hunt for some low cut booties that will look equally nice with jeans as with skirts for fall. Unfortunately, I could barely get my foot into this bootie. I am sure with some effort I might have been able to break them in, however, I wanted a go-to pair of booties to leave by the door and slip on as I rush out. They also make my foot look longer for some reason. Frye has great quality, but they are being returned.

Shoe was hard to get on. Zipper hard to move. Longer than should have been and narrower. Love Frye but this style not for me

I wish Frye made these in a size 5. I normally wear between a 5.5 and 6 and find that Frye's styles are great but they run about a half size too big. Sadly these gorgeous shoes are going back.

So comfortable from the very first day!

Fit was normal for me. I’m an 8.5 and that’s what I ordered. Good leather. These were definitely knock offs. They came in a black box. I’ve 5 pairs of Fryes and not one has ever come in anything but a white box. You get what you pay for. These are little over $100 less than the original.

I bought these on sale using a Zappos 10% off code. The fit was not great and I did not like the color so returned.

The color is more like butternut squash than cognac. The picture on Zappos is way off. I bought the Carson bootie in Sea Pine and they are a dream to wear. These shooties left blisters on my heels and small toe- and I had toe protectors on.. I will stretch them and seek out a professional shoe dye service. All in all for the price disappointing. Probably not buying anything else from Zappos due to the color issue. I love Frye but not the hassle that comes with this purchase.

Perfect fit and stylish.

These lovely rose suede shoes were quite comfortable straight out of the box, unlike most other Fryes I own. This style may run large for some; it did for me. I am reliably a 6B, but had to exchange for a 5.5. Once the switch was accomplished I really wanted to be wearing them out and about- unfortunately COVID-19 squashed that dream - but the few opportunities I’ve had to leave the house in them have been super comfy for me, both barefoot in the summer & now with tights in the fall. Many many compliments. Right now they are at my ace shoe repair guy having protection applied to the soles/heels so I can still wear them now that our PNW weather has turned quite wet. He immediately commented on the excellent workmanship and beautiful styling of these shoes. I would definitely recommend weatherizing these leather soles if you will be wearing them in rainy weather. Can’t wait to pick them up!

Very cute and fit well, was just too similar to a style I already had, otherwise would've kept. Great shoe otherwise!

Another super Frye shoe. My only caution is that I am an A width and it fits me perfectly. The leather is so soft that I expect it will stretch gradually. I can easily wear these all day as the design is so supportive of my foot, and of course it's great looking and stylish. Just love these! It's another addition to my Frye collection.

This was my first pair of Frye booties and I was not disappointed. They are incredibly comfy right out of the box. I've already worn them several times and I can tell I'll be wearing them often. Look cute with skinnies and jeans.

Bought these for my daughter. She's a 10 in Frye. These were perfect fit. Super cute and very stylish!!

I originally ordered these gorgeous shoes in my usual 6M, as with all of my other Fryes and most every other brand I own. The 6M was enormous; sent them back for a 5.5M, crossing fingers that the half size down would do the trick. Thankfully, it did - good thing, as Frye does not offer these in a 5. The 5.5M fits perfectly with thin socks or tights, and will probably be fine even barefoot in warmer months. The color is absolutely beautiful - not too pink; the contours of the shoe look great on my weird feet; and as for comfort - they do feel like gloves, snug but not tight, and the leather lining is sumptuous. I will apply suede protector, but even so I will wait for drier weather to confidently wear them outside in super-rainy Western Oregon. I can't wait!

Love these! I’m amazed how comfortable they were right out of the box! They’re also super cute. I bought an 8 and usually wear an 8 or 8.5. Most of my Frye boots are 8.5 but these were perfect for me at 8. The color is lovely in the brandy oiled suede. I do spray with scotchgard and recommend doing so.

I wear a 7.5 or an 8 depending on the style with Frye. The 7.5 was perfect, the 8 felt too big all around. I wore these all day right out of the box and they were so comfortable. Love them with skinny pants or jeans and no sox. I love these! I got the black and will get a ton of wear with these shoes. Perfection.

I absolutely love these shooties. I ordered them in the Rosewood and they are a perfect color/not color to add a little pop but not be too bright. I think the picture makes them look a little bit more pink than they actually are. I did order another pair a half size smaller as I feel my typically ordered size is a bit too long. Who knows, I may keep the original size ordered but don’t think I need that added length. We’ll see. Thanks to Zappos good customer service and quick shipping I’ll get it figured out soon.

Love from the moment I slipped my foot into these Frye shooties. I had been eyeing these for some time and I finally took the plunge to add them to my collection & I'm happy I did. I'm going to order them in another color. That's how much I love them. I"m a 9.5 but often take a 10 in sneakers and boots. The 9.5 is perfect in this style.