Customer Reviews KEEN Hoodoo III Slip-On Waterproof

I was looking forward to this waterproof Keen shoe, but the toe box is not roomy, even with thin socks. I also did not like the stiffness and height of the front top of the shoe that caused an uncomfortable rub. Perhaps it was a defective piece.

I got a 9 and the length is fine but the shoe overall is too wide. I'm always seduced by Keen's roomy toe box but my foot is probably just too narrow for the brand.

Loved these shoes but the vamp came up to too high making them uncomfortable. Sent them back, unfortunately. Have lots of other Keen shoes and they have all fit well.

Love Keene and these did not disappoint. I did have to return my size 9 and exchange for a 9.5 as I think they run a 1/2-size smaller. Love they are waterproof and they look great for a casual shoe with jeans.

I'm so disappointed in this shoe because I have loved my older Keen shoes. It seems in the last few years they are not as true to size, I've worn the same size Keens for many years. Keens have worked so well for me because of their usual wide toe bed, however these feel pretty narrow. The front comes up a bit high for me and irritates. On a brighter note, the leather in this shoe is great. I wish they weren't so narrow.

These shoes are really comfortable with the exception of the lip which digs into the front of my ankle. Sadly I'll be returning the shoes because of that. I did order 1/2 size up from my usual size with the recommendation of several reviews. Shortening the lip by about 1/2 inch would make this a perfect shoe.

I liked the shoe overall. Good style. Nice flat sole. The problem was the top of the right shoe hit up against my leg. So with every step it jammed into me. Not sure if it is something that would soften up if broken in, but the Kaci style fits so much more comfortably I will be sending these back.

These are my favorite out-and-about shoes when the weather is not too warm. They are great for walking, even feel great just sitting still.

Very comfortable, as all Keen styles are for me. I was able to wear them out on a walk with my dogs the first day, and no problems. Waterproof and very nice for walking.

Supple leather and superior comfort from the first day wearing.

Tough to put on...a bit tight but otherwise ok.

I really like this shoe and was looking for something I could wear all day in the garden but I found it to be a full size too small. I normally wear size 7 in Keens but the 7 and 7.5 were both too tight. The upper was also too close or too high and rubbed against the front of my foot. I like the Kaci II and it fits better but I thought the suede would be ruined more easily in the garden.

I love the leather on this "boot", however it seems to run narrow, not like a true Keen. I'm concerned the length may be too long and slip around with the next size up because I did that with my last pair years ago. They last.

Too tight across top of foot..would have to go to next size up with even a thin sock.

While the size I ordered turned out to be a full size too big, I am not reordering. The edge of the shoe near the ankle bone protrudes and is actually painful. I believe the same problem would exist in the next size down due to the design. The style is functional but is not aesthetically appealing in any way. It looks like the kind of shoe you'd wear at work -- only.

Looks like it could be comfortable but it is not.