Customer Reviews UGG Shelby Matte

I ordered 4 pairs of rain boots on Zappos to finally choose these. I bought the shorter Uggs first and because I have small calves, they were just too wide at the top. Then I bought the gloss black Shelby and liked the height of them much more and the better arch support. I also ordered the original hunter boot that was expandable to check them out. They were too tall almost hitting my knee and puddled at the ankles. No support at all in the foot and I have high arches. The adjustable strap was wonky to deal with. They went back immediately. Have heard good things about Hunter but the reviews were true. I traded the gloss shelby for the matte because I don't want to deal with water spots on the gloss. I am an 8.5 and never size down. I ordered a 9 and they are the right size.

So I ordered these and the Kamik Olivia (size 8) to compare and both were definite keepers. UGG says to order a size down (I'm a 7 1/2) and that worked. The size 7 fit great. Love the warmth in the sole and they are comfortable to walk in. I did like the Olivia's but were just a bit too narrow at the ankle which made them too "hard" to pull on and off. Not that I couldn't but I just like to be able to slip into them more easily.

I wear 7.5, but the 8 was too big, so I kept the 7. The sole of the boot feels warm & fuzzy on your feet. They aren’t super comfortable, as they hit my calves oddly when I walk, but I think all rainboots are like this.

First of all, I love Zappos! Customer Service is excellent. Very competitive prices. I love UGGs too, but this was a flop! It was hard. It was hard to walk in. I looked good, but it was not comfortable at all. I returned it. Of course, the next day Zappos emailed me of refund! Kudos, Zappos! This will not stop me from shopping shoes with you. I have shared you with a couple besties.

These are very cute for rainboots. Love the furry, cushioned insole! I just wish they were comfortable to walk in! The shaft hit my calf and shin strangly as I walked, plus they rubbed my ankles. Bummer!!

I knew to size one down due to other reviews. This is a good quality rain boot with a nice fur lining. I wore all day to work and I’m on my feet a lot. That being said, I probably wouldn’t wear for a three mile outdoor hike.

These are fantastic! I was on the fence for several reasons. Are they going to be too heavy? Definitely not. I've worn them for hours without a problem. Will they be too big? Nope fit perfect for me. I'm between 5.5 and 6. I purchased the 6 and can wear with thin to medium thick socks (not thick winter wool) or no socks at all and they're still comfortable. Will I look like a kid in too big galoshes? Thankfully no. I'm 5'2 and they still work with dresses like a pullover hoodie dress and with leggings. Not too tall or too big around the calf. I debated between the patent vs matte and decided I didn't want to worry about scratches so I went with the Navy matte. Highly recommend for work and fashion.

Fitting perfect, style is very nice, rubber feels soft and comfortable. Love them!

I bought these for my mom. I own a pair and are very comfortable for rain boots. I like that’s it’s matte. The shiny ones are cute too but I have to constantly wipe finger prints off. As far as the size. I usually wear 7 in all ugg boots, with these I purchased the 8. I have room to wear “thick mountain” socks and still feel comfortable. Without thick socks they do fit loose.

Perfect boots ! I had been wanting some Hunter boots for a long time but I couldn’t see paying $$$. These are so comfortable and so cute . I bought the green and they go with everything.

These are the most comfortable rain boots. I wear them a decent amount, so I wanted something comfortable. I tried on some Hunters, and had previously some Kamiks...Neither compare to these. For one, a lot easier to get on and off. SO that is a plus. It helps that they don't have the funky rubber feel, since that tends to make your foot stick inside. I wear them to give the dogs baths, out on my property since there is wet grass, and when I wash my car. So they get a significant amount of use. So far so good. I have many other ugg boots, the waterproof leather winter boots and love those too.