Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Sentinel Waterproof Hiker Boot

The boots are out-of-control comfortable. I wore them for the first time yesterday for over 13 hours, and I did not want to take them off...even when it was time for bed. I haven't tested them out in the snow, or extreme cold, but in 40-degree weather, my feet were toasty all day. Great boot.

I have purchased Dr. Scholl's brand before, so I've experienced the challenge with the right sizing in this brand. If your foot is an average width, you will need to go up at least a half size. I am generally a 9.5 and needed a 10. Once you get past that, I can tell you that these are probably the most comfortable booties I've ever had. I love these things. The fabric upper is advertised as waterproof, though I haven't tried it in the rain and would be skeptical given that they are a wool blend. Otherwise, I find them to be incredibly comfortable and I am very happy with this purchase.

Cute, but returned because a little tight in the toe area. Would also go up 1/2 size.

I love these shoes! I needed a pair of lace up, warm ankle boots for cold weather. These are perfect and a bonus they are waterproof. They are really comfortable and warm. On both days I wore them out of the house and when I came home I didn't take them off until bedtime. They have great support. My feet are somewhat narrow and these are perfect. Might not work so well for really wide feet.

Ran rather small and narrow. I wear dress shoe size 7.5 and boot size 8 (for additional room and heavy socks). I ordered size 8 and they are still a bit narrow and a bit short - cannot fit a thick sock. Will return and purchase size 9, as I love the look and general feel of boot.

These shoes have are extremely comfortable - as with other Dr. Scholl's I've had, the sole provides excellent cushion and the materials are comfortable and are of good quality. However, the toe box is a bit small and narrow. I ordered a half size bigger to accommodate for this and after breaking them in (took about 20 minutes of wear), they fit very well. I still wouldn't mind a little more wiggle room for my toes as they are still a little snug, but the overall comfort and style make up for it. Oh - they are much warmer than I anticipated, but that's not a bad thing.

Cute comfortable boot for a bit of fall winter style. Love the gray wool like fabric- perfect for Saturday shopping with jeans and a flannel shirt!

Really love these. Stylish and comfy. They are a little toasty when you’re running around on your feet all day.

Cute, comfortable boots. Fit great from day one- I’m a size 10 medium width and I use a light arch support and it slipped right in with room to spare. I sprayed the grey fabric to make it even more water/ snow resistant and I’m good to go.

These boots were really cute, and since Dr. Scholl's usually work for me in my usual size 9, I thought they would be super comfortable. However, they were much more narrow in the toes than expected, but at the same time, I felt the heal area was a bit loose for me. Sadly had to return.

This is a super cute boot but there is no arch support at all and I can't take out to footbed to get mine in. Also, the tongue doesn't lie flat so it's bulky between the laces or uncomfortable on the top of your foot. Sadly I'm returning them.

As other reviewers have noted, this boot is hard to fit. The toe box is impossibly narrow and I tend to have a narrow foot. I tried a 7.5 (my usual size), an 8 (my sometimes sizes) and an 8.5 (my almost-never size) and they were all too narrow in the foot box. My toes were so cramped after I walked around in them just a bit. Way too bad since it is a good looking boot and I could tell they'd be very warm. But, they are going back.

This boot is so streamlined and cute! Unfortunately, I had to return four different pairs. I loved them so much I kept trying for the sizing. I initially went a half size up and still too small so ordered a full size up and way too large. I again ordered a half size up from my original, and it fit better but not well. I tried one last time with the same size and alas the same issue. I have extremely narrow and thin feet. This fit well in the width, however the toe box from the top of the foot to the bottom is very short putting a lot of pressure on the top of my foot at the toes leaving zero room for a decent sock as well as hurt my foot. I usually can't find shoes narrow enough from side to side or top to bottom, so this is an usually fitting shoe.

These shoes did not fit me at all. I tried my regular size and they were too small. I went to a 9.5 and they still didn't feel right on my foot. I think for me, they were too narrow. I did like how they looked and thought they'd be a great shoe for the coming winter. But sadly, no.