Customer Reviews Steve Madden Eldridge Buffalo Plaid Coat

I really like this jacket and I will keep it but it does pull through the upperarms when you stretch your arms forward. You are aware it's tight in your biceps area for some reason but I really like the coat so I will keep it. I am 5'2" and weigh 135 and got a medium. It runs a little small, I usually get a small in most clothing but I needed a medium in this coat. It is pretty long, it comes to about 2 " above my knees. I hope this helps someone else with my height and weight included so they can buy the right size for them because this coat is pretty and cozy.

Would be a great jacket but the sleeves are way way too short; like above my wrists! I'm 5'6", 140, ordered the medium. Was also a little tight across the back and when I reach forward the sleeves hike up to the elbows. Definite design flaw. Color is great; got the green and it's not too bright. Material is med weight, unlined, good for Fall, but definitely scratchy. Would be uncomfortable in short sleeves. Long sleeves wouldn't fit under it anyway. Sending back.

I really love the length of this. I was worried it might be too long for the look. It’s adorable, comfortable, and warm enough for a chilly day. Fits true to size. I’m a medium in most items, this medium fits great!

It's very long, almost to my knees and I'm 5'5'', its really a coat! Not sure if I will keep, Its seems I should size down, but might be comfy when really cold and need length coverage for warmth. Well made and do like, just debating on length.

Great quality and super on trend. I'm 5'8" and 135 lbs, and I went for a medium.

Fit is true to size except for the sleeves which, as others noted, are very tight at the top arms...noticeably tight when wearing. Also, description says it is lined but IT IS NOT lined which makes it stick to sweaters. Returning.

Lots of compliments at work. Comfortable.

very good

very nice and very good

I absolutely love this thing. It’s roomy but not baggy and feels so comfortably and cozy without being itchy. It looks great, has held up well, and fits perfectly. I’m 5’7” and 140, not curvy but not super thin. I’ve worn it with a thin tshirt under it as well as a thick sweater.

Love the coat and XS fit perfectly. Tag says is 5% wool but is very scratchy. Had to return.

I want to love this coat, it’s so flattering and warm, but just too darn itchy!

Love the pattern and length of this but it was fit weird. I tried xs and small. Both were too tight in the area where you bend your elbows. The xs and small both fit in the shoulders but on the small it flared out making me looking bigger. Like a pear shape. It is also itchy. You would definitely have to wear a long sleeve under it.

too small in the shoulders. I am going to try a larger size.

I tracked this jacket down after seeing someone wearing it at Whole Foods, it's very striking in person. This jacket is a heavy wool material and has quality stitching. Unfortunately, the fabric was incredibly itchy and it's heavy dense weave means that it is felt through turtle necks and shirts underneath. This is literally the itchy wool sweater that made you cry from your childhood. I don't know if they didn't process the fabric or used a lower quality wool, but I was super disappointed immediately upon trying it on for sizing. I have so many other wool sweaters, socks and long underwear and was somewhat shocked at how abrasive and itchy this was for the price-point. I ended up returning it without even wearing it. So bummed because otherwise the fit was great and it's very chic. If itchy wool doesn't bother you, here is the sizing: 5'8" about 135lbs (size 4) and ordered the Small. The jacket is narrower in the shoulder and tapers out for hips.

too scratchy and big

This is so scratchy and stiff.

The fit is horrible.