Customer Reviews TOMS Shaye

Love this shoe! I’ve always been a big fan of TOMS, but their boots are changing the game. So cute and comfy! They were true to size for me, fitting much like all of the other TOMS shoes I own. Would definitely buy these and other TOMS boots in the future.

Agree with others that Desert Taupe is lighter than it appears in photos. Very comfortable heel height - and I rarely wear any heel anymore. The initial fit is a little snug, not uncomfortably so but trying to decide how it would feel after a few hours of wear. As always with Toms, no particular hot spots or binding bits inside the shoe, just slightly snug.

They are sooo cute. But sooo tight! I have a somewhat wider normal than average foot, but I can usually get away with ordering a 1/2 size up. Not these. Ooh - my poor foot thought it was going to suffocate! Hope they come out with W-width in the future.

I adore these shoes, though my wider feet are not super comfortable in them after a long day of standing/running around. But I continue to wear them because they are the perfect little ankle bootie to get me through winters in Chicago.

These Toms were perfection straight out of the box! Super comfortable and stylish for Fall. I don't have to wear socks, which is how I prefer the look with an ankle shoe/bootie. I'm a 6.5 in shoe size, but prefer to go up to a 7.0 when it comes to booties. The 7.0 feels wonderful. Do it...you will nOt be disappointed!!

I got my Toms Shaye booties about 2 weeks ago and have been wearing them inside at home (it is has still been flip flop weather here until today!) to make sure they are a good fit. I have worn them without socks and they seem fine. I ordered an 8 1/2 (I wear 8 1/2-9 depending) and they fit perfectly. I love the style and color (I got the Desert Taupe). I am looking forward to actually wearing them out in public tonight!!

These are my first pair of Toms and I absolutely love them! True to size and super stylish and comfortable. I am wearing them for the first day and no need to break them in. I actually bought three more pairs! Wish they made a Navy color as well, hopefully soon!!

Fit well, but the heel was squeaky on me. I'm usually an 8.5 in Toms slip ons, but highly recommend sizing up half a size for any boot type.

These TOMS Shaye are so cool. Love the two-color look! Nice shape, just like the picture, seems to be good quality. The black with black and white back has a fun blue sparkly thread in the pattern. Really great looking. I ordered a half size up 9.5M instead of 9M, because my size was not available, and it's fine for someone like me who really is a M, not wide or narrow foot. So they might be a little snug in usual size esp if you have a wide foot. They are comfortable, probably not ideal for walking miles or being on your feet all day, but great for wearing to work.

I love the style of this shoe, however, the only color available in my size was Dusty Gold Star Suede and, unfortunately, the photo doesn't clearly show that there are gold sparkles. That wasn't to my liking, so I returned them. I would buy a pair in taupe or dark amber if available.

I bought these boots in the fall of 2018 and I absolutely love them! I get constant compliments whenever I wear them and they are so super comfortable. I just looked up in my history to make sure what I had ordered so I could get another pair in a different color, but I was disappointed to find they don’t come in black. However in my search I found some Tom’s sunglasses I think will be perfect!

I just opened the box and I'm seriously in love! They are immediately comfortable, stylish, and just perfect! My ankles tend to roll inward and i can never find an ankle boot that looks right. These hit my ankle in the perfect spot. They will definitely become my main shoe as I can dress them up or down with ease!

Loved the look of this shoe. Would love to have gotten other colors but didn't care for the design on the back of the other colors. Shoe is pretty comfy but I had to add an arch support to it. Wish the insoles were removeable.

I love these shoes! They are a great fit and very stylist. I have stiff feet and these shoes provide the right support. I don't think I could walk for 10 miles, but I can wear them casually and to work.

Comfort right out of box! As expected great shoe.

I just ordered my third pair - desert suede is my go-to for every day wear with skinny jeans and no-show socks. Black is great with leggings and skirts. Blush is on the way! I've seen them styled with scrunched down socks for a boho feel, which I may try. I even got these for Christmas gifts I love them so much. On the first wear, I walked / ran / sprinted for miles in NYC with no problem. I will be taking these to Europe with me this year for sure. Get them before they're gone!

One of the most comfortable shoes ever!

Received the shoes about a week ago. When I first put them on I felt they may be a little tight, but after wearing around the house they loosened up to a very comfortable fit. Very comfortable with no socks and very thin socks. The desert taupe is quite a bit grayer than the pics, they appear much more brown in the ad. Overall a good shoe, the real test will be how to the wear over time.

So comfortable and stylish!

Love these shoes! Great style and really comfortable. My first pair of Tom's, and happy to find a pair with a moderate heel, instead of flats. Great Zappos service too!

Love the style and heel height of these shoes. They were very confortable from when I first put them on and did not need to be broken in. I take a size 5. I highly recommend TOMS.

Awesome so comfortable I really didn't want to take them off! First pair of This brand ever ! No breaking in required.

My first pair of TOMS and overall very pleased. I waited a while before reviewing because honestly there was a break in period for me, but now I love them! Very stylish with leggings or jeans. The color I chose has just a little sparkle but not gaudy at all. I’ve had hip surgery and these are very stable and comfy after break in.

Super comfortable! The pair I received is kind of folded over on the top, but I have no worries Zappos will replace them! Would totally recommend. Run true to size, and do not run as narrow as Tom's booties seem to.

Comfortable and cute. Wear this shoe with so many different outfits. Love these shoes!