Customer Reviews Columbia Minx Shorty III

Very comfortable, like that they're waterproof. Only thing that disappoints is there is no arch support.

Gets the job done which is to keep your feet dry and warm. I would have liked for it to have a sturdier sole as it feels like I'm walking in a foam slipper. Some might like this kind of comfort in a boot but it was an adjustment to not feel like I might lose my balance and fall.

Good quality, Wisconsin weather gets crazy during winter but this boots keep my feet warm and dry, I got my regular size which is 7.5 and they fit perfect

These boots were warm and comfy, but I don't absolutely LOVE them. Can't put my finger on what exactly it is that makes me only like them....but five stars just seems a bit out of their reach.

Runs extra small. I usually wear a 6.5-7 wide or extra wide. Ordered these in a 7.5 wide and my foot was squished on all sides. I love the look, they're super cozy and would be great for commuting but I'm nervous that going up to 8 or 8.5 still wouldn't be enough. If you have normal or narrow feet I'm sure these fit just fine, but if you have wide feet proceed with caution.

They look so pretty, so warm, they have all features that I was looking for a winter boots but. I am so sad that I need to return the item because I bought wide width but they are not. And also you need to buy one size more. I hope that you have regular feet and bought them because they are soooo pretty and have many amazing features.

These are warm and decently comfortable. I've worn them on short walks but wouldn't wear them for prolonged hikes. Better for casual wear but still warm and cozy!

I recently got these and started wearing them immediately. I would normally wear 10ww but WW isn't an option so I bought 10.5W. They're a little snug so no big fluffy socks for me, but still comfortable enough to wear all day, would definitely recommend!

I have these same boots in the cream color and the tall black ones. I LOVE them! They're so comfortable and the insoles are so cushiony!! It's like walking on a cloud! That being said, I ordered these red ones and I don't know if you changed the insoles or what but they are very stiff and not at all like my other two. I pressed on the insoles and they're not as soft as the others. I returned them because I knew I'd not wear them since they weren't as comfy. I was going to order my sister a pair but I'm unsure if the insoles of all the colors have changed to this new one. I hope not cuz I do love these boots.

I've been wearing the woman's minx mid III boots for 3 years and wanted another pair for the cold but snowless days of winter in Wisconsin. The Minx Shorty III are tight, but that is to be expected since the Minx Mid III were also tight when I first got them. After breaking them in, they are very comfortable shoes and I can wear them all day. They used to cut off circulation before I broke them in. Another issue with these boots is that your feet will get nice and toasty if you wear them the whole day - I recommend bringing in a backup pair of shoes if you work in an office. They're very cute and lightweight. They're not as easy to slip on compared to the Minx Mid III, but they come off pretty easily without untying the laces.

Very comfortable and keep your feet warm. Only downside was it ran on the smaller side so would be tight with thicker socks if needed for hikes in cold weather

For the most part, I love this boot, it has kept my feet warm and dry, which is much needed in our Seattle weather. However, I wish there were a tab on the back of this boot so it's easier to put on. I struggle to put it on.

Love these boots. A lot warmer than other boots I have; love the color, fit, style. Could use a little tab on the back for pulling on - but not that bad in terms of getting them on my feet. Getting the wider boot worked perfect for me in terms of getting my normal size.

Nice boots, but runs smaller than expected in the toe area