Customer Reviews TOMS Carlo

As shoes, these are pretty much useless. My Toms slippers have more support than these. The foam on the inside went flat pretty much the first time I wore them outside my house. Live in a cold climate? You'd be advised not to stop at crosswalks, or your feet will go numb from the cold sidewalk that is 2 millimeters below your feet. Need to run to catch a bus? You'll have bruises on your feet. Walk more than .5 miles in a day? Your dogs will be barking for that .5 mile and anything afterwards. Nice looking shoes, though.

I hate these shoes. Probably won't buy Tom's again. They are very Ridgid at first and hard to get your feet into. When you get your feet into them you will quickly realize that Tom's designers think all humans have 4 toes. They actually have 5, too bad these shoes aren't wide enough for all 5. The shoes are also just so poorly ventilated. Ny feet sweat, like many folks do, and I wear wool socks to help wick moisture. And keep my feet dry. The shoes trap all that moisture in, so much so that the canvas is actually stained from it just saying and soaking into the shoe. (See photo.) I have had mediocre shoes before, but these shoes I can actually say I hate. 0/10. Do not buy.

Exactly what I was looking for. Very minimal. As comfortable as expected for such a simple canvas shoe. Not much arch support. I wear 8 1/2 in all other shoes and they felt true to size. Pretty narrow. Narrow toe box. Could've probably gone up a half size for a little more room in the two box but the length was just right. Will order again.

These shoes are too narrow. I don’t usually have trouble with that. I was hoping they would stretch, but no such luck after a couple months of wearing them.

They are a touch long compared to all of my other shoes of the same size. I ripped out the insole (cushion does not equal arch support) and put in a pair of my superfeet, which fit in the shoe great. Overall I am very comfortable in these shoes. I took away a star because they scrape the skin on my heel. Waiting to see if this gets better once broken in.

They’re alright. I’m glad I got them on sale because these are not worth the full price. They fit fine but for whatever reason they just aren’t very comfortable

These are very stylish and fit well, but they are super squeaky!

I would not give these shoes to my worst enemy. I've had them now for 5 months and they still give me blisters every time I wear them. I did not know it was possible to make such an uncomfortable shoe. The fact that TOMS may be giving these shoes to people in need should be considered a crime.

These shoes fit as expected! They're a great casual work or everyday shoe.

These run a little large I am Usually a size 9m I needed to change to a 8.5m for this shoe..I love the fit now !!!!!

Nice, comfortable right out of the box

Excellent shoe, from the moment I opened the box to the first steps. It looks great, with high quality materials, and surprisingly cushy given its minimalist look. Not sure how they may wear out, but judging from another pair of Toms I have, they will age nicely.

Great shoe for casual work attire. Comfortable

Very comfortable pair of TOMS. the bright color looks very sharp with a pair of black pants and solid black t-shirt. My son gets a lot of compliments on them.

Great shoes for the summer.

They feel as good as they look.

I love these Toms. I like the low profile and the tact that it only has three lace eyelets on each side (it doesn't look 'busy') and they felt like I had already worn them in for months. I love them!

I've been looking for a good replacement for mens Keds Champions for years. This is the closest I've found and I just wish TOMS would make more colors!

Very comfortable and light weight.

Love them

These shoes are awesome. Love them!

I found these while ordering a pair of the classic TOMS and I'm very happy with my purchase! They are a great color and design and fit great ( I always order them a half size smaller). The only recommendation is buy some no show socks with this pair!