Customer Reviews KEEN Presidio II Waterproof Mid Zip Boot

I absolutely LOVE these boots. Very comfortable for long walks . Were comfortable right out of the box too. I wore them to walk to work on a very snowy, icy winter morning and they provided warmth , dryness , good traction and comfort. I will probably order another pair .

They are not my first choice for "cute boot," but they look nicer than I thought they would. But...the comfort! It's like walking on a cloud! Possibly the most comfortable shoes I have ever owned. Thank you, Keen!

It's not easy finding a waterproof boot that doesn't feel heavy and stiff. These will be perfect for DC's very wet, cold weather. Keens have been a go to shoe for me for years.

I bought these boots for my mom (who's in her 60s). She thought they were a decent boot for lightly snowy days. She found them too tight across the top, though, so ultimately we're returning them. Seems like they're best suited for folks who have more narrow feet or people who aren't worried about wearing thick layers of socks.

This boot is so comfortable, it cradles and supports my feet so I feel confident it would be good to wear all day shopping. However, I can only have one pair of good boots, and the style is just not that attractive. They are wonderfully serviceable - just very plain.These have to go back-

I am likely returning these.... I bought Merrell Andover Bluff and these and will keep the Merrell ones. These run larger than my other Keen shoes. I have another pair of Keen shoes in a size 9.5 and had to go to 9 for these boots. They are fairly comfortable (if I change out the insert.... I have high arches and there is not enough support in these). The look of the shoes is more casual than I am looking for. They are fine with jeans but will not work as well with a skirt. When I travel, I want to have a single pair of boots that I can use with multiple outfits.

Definitely love these boots...as I have all of the Keen boots I've tried over the past few months. Unfortunately, none of them fit my strangely wide right foot...not even the men's Anchorage boot. It seems that Keen no longer offers the wide toe bed of some of their previous models like the Dakota and older Presidio model. When I measure these Presidios and the Anchorage against my trusty Dakotas, the width is about 1/4 to 1/2 inch narrower. Seeing as how I'm at the top of the women's sizes (11 to 11.5) I guess I'm just going to have to find another brand of shoes. I'm soooo grateful to Zappos for their fabulous customer service and return policy. Local shoe stores rarely carry size 11's so I'd be barefooted and lost without Zappos!!! I guess I'm back to my search....

I returned these Keen Presidio II waterproof mid-zip boots for a few reasons, the most compelling of which was the fit. I have a wide foot with a high arch, and Keen shoes and boots typically fit me well. Not this pair: The width at the ball of my foot was too tight; the width at the heel was too loose. The style was also surprisingly frumpy. I know Keens have a certain look, but these were almost orthopedic in appearance. I don't remember if the footbed was comfortable.

I also ordered the Kaci Winter and kept them. They felt great and fit good. These boots, although they look similar to the Kaci and were the same size, fit differently. They rubbed my toe. I really wanted these to work for winter gardening but, alas, they have been sent back.

I *so* wanted to love these, but I can't. They're exactly what I wanted in terms of style and performance, but they're just too narrow. I've worn a B/Medium all my life, never needed a wide style, but these press in on both sides as well as the top of my instep. I'm so disappointed. Style and quality are excellent. If you happen to have narrow feet, go for it.

I wanted a basic waterproof boot that was warm enough for slushy days. This one fits the bill. The boot is wide and roomy, has nice arch support. Not big on style, as is typical of Keens' frumpy look, but fine for most purposes.

I typically wear an 8 wide athletic shoe. The size 8 fit nicely, but I decided to exchange it for an 8.5 to have a more room for my toes. The boot is well made and has a footbed that can be removed to accommodate my Powerstep orthotic inserts.

Perfect boot! Bought taller this pair of PresidioII mid boot because I loved the taller boot so much! I never realized how a pair of extremely comfortable boots can make you feel good all over! I can’t get over how happy my feet are! Seriously! I Lived the way they look too. I feel like they were custom made they fit so well. I love the color of my first pair. I think it was called “Wine”. My second pair are “Tortoise”. Also a great color. Might not fit do perfectly if you have a narrow foot. The size I ordered was what I always order and I didn’t feel I needed to “break them it”. So comfortable they could be slippers. Feet are toasty and dry. Never been so happy with a shoe purchase!

I LOVE these. That’s saying a lot because this is my first pair of new shoes after 3-4 years of only wearing running shoes and two recent bunion surgeries. I ordered these and the Kaci shirt boots in my usual Keen size from many years ago (9); these felt 1/2 size too big and the Kaci felt 1/2 size too small. These in 8.5 are so comfortable I wear them day after day to work. They’re still very roomy even in the smaller size. I especially like that there’s nothing on the top/front of the shoe to be tight or irritating, just nice smooth leather. So, so happy.

Keen tortoise shell Presidio II. I have hallux rigidus and need shoes that do not flex. It is really challenging to find shoes that will also accommodate a wide-ish front foot with a narrow heel and high instep. There are rigid but are pretty comfortable. I have to struggle to get them over my instep, however, and they are tight over the instep, so I have to decide whether the leather will stretch out over the top. If you don't have a high instep, these would be perfect!

I am so disappointed!! I love my Keen shoes, and expected the same comfy, roomy fit in this boot of the same size. Alas, I am returning. Not sure they make ‘em

These are exactly what I was looking for - a cute and functional boot for camping, casual days, and yucky weather. I usually wear 9.5 though occasionally 9... and it turns out i should have gone with the 9 on these. The 9.5 is a little roomy even with thicker socks, but I wore them camping right away and luckily they're not so big I can't live with it, since I have to keep them now. Be warned and consider sizing down. The bonus is I can slip them off and sometimes on without unzipping. The back elastic is comfortable so that even if you wear a sock shorter than the boot, nothing chafes.

These are very cute booties and comfortable to wear right out of the box. Unfortunately, the left foot was a bit smaller than the right in length so I'm having to return them. Otherwise I would keep. Because I have a high arch It is a real problem to find boots I can even get on my foot. So when length is the problem it is a real disappointment. With regard to size, it felt a half size smaller on the left foot only.

Love these boots. My daughter had a pair and I told her I would like to buy a pair. She told me what they were and I bought them on her recommendation. They are comfortable, fit well, and look good.

I love these boots and I can see that they will last forever. However, my review isn't against the product. As I get older, my feet have changed and difficult for me to find ones that are comfortable. These rubbed my right big toe and I knew it would be uncomfortable in the long run because I was wearing them around the house to 'test drive' them.

Cute, soft and roomy; will help me be fearless in the rain! The vertical strip in back looks orange online, but in reality, is a warm brown.

I really wanted to love these boots. They are waterproof , well made and have a classic style. For some reason the Keen booties seem to be too wide in the heel and too narrow in the ankle.

This bootie fits consistently with other Presidios, but I think the wide heel causes it to slip too much for real comfort. Otherwise, it is is nice footwear.

Wish Keen either made sz 12.

These would be great boots for those with feet that are medium width. Unfortunately, they slip right off my feet. I need to choose something with laces.