Customer Reviews Deer Stags Mitch Boat Shoe

Very Comfortable, should have ordered 1/2 size smaller.

Felt good soft material easy on feet

Bought these for my husband for a beach wedding we have coming up. They look great but they are extremely big. He typically wears a 10 1/2 and we had to go with a 9. A full size and a half smaller! Not sure why these run so large.

Good quality, nice looking.and great price

Good item for the price, shoelaces are way too long though, I an a size 9 I had to exchange for 8.5 abd even those felt a little loose..they are good looking with shorts.

Very nice look and feel but running a size large - I always wear 10 1/2 and i could wear a 91/2 in these!

The fit and size were just fine. The shoes were daily office shoes for about 4 months before they started to break down a little. Spend a little bit more for the Sperry brand, in my opinion.

Loose

At least a full size bigger than marked.

Good overall. Just a bit disappointed on the memory foam.

Fantastic looking, well-made, super comfortable shoes. I am mostly interested in a casual shoe to wear with a sport coat and jeans in an office setting. These shoes fit the bill perfectly except for the huge size. I have worn an 11 E shoe for decades, but these shoes are almost one full size larger than the 11 D size stated. For a (D) Medium width, my feet were swimming in there, even with thick Dockers work socks. I really want these shoes, but I'm not sure whether to order a 10 or a 10.5. Boat shoes typically do not have arch support, but these shoes have a memory foam base and moderate arch support for long days on your feet. So in my opinion, these "kicks" are fantastic quality and are very good looking and feeling but please order at least a half size smaller than normal.

I prefer my shoes to be crafted from real leather, not the synthetic (man-made) variety. In addition, the shoe laces are ridiculously long. A design defect in my opinion.

Material was great but shoes ran half size small. Kinda tight but hoping will expand with wear

i liked them out of the box however they were noticably wider than i expected kind of swishy wide

Way too big- over a full size larger

I am returning these they are way to large.

With Sperry increasing their boat shoe prices every year, I've had good luck with generic alternatives on Zappos. This was not one of them: you get what you pay for. They fit extremely wide, are clunky, and made of very poor materials. After ~15 brief uses, the interior material right on the Achilles tendon wore through, exposing the bare plastic to my foot. I threw the shoes away after a half-mile walk cut my foot multiple places. Would not recommend these even if on a budget.

The shoes are entirely too big. I wear a 10.5, sometimes a size 11. I ordered Deer Stags Mitch Boat Shoe in sizes 10.5, the 10.0, and the 9.5 and they're all too big. My heel pulls out and there is too much side to side volume. My foot swims around in this shoe. I've given up on trying to get a good fit. I like the look of the shoe. The shoe appears to be well made.

Far too wide for the length. If one were to choose a smaller size to get the width right, then they would be too short.

Show has minimal arch support but for me needs an orothotic. Also be sure to cut back about one full size for length and width when ordering. I might send them back as they are not for me to wear outdoors but as an indoor type of slipper maybe would be ok. Not that comfortable. Only plus for me is they are not expensive.

Good God steer clear of these “shoes” - haven’t had them for even three months and the bottoms are separating & the soles are wearing-away (from light-duty use by a sedentary retired guy). Combined with too-long laces and too-short tongues these are the first shoes I’ve regretted purchasing in many years. Do yourself a favor: no matter how discounted buy something else… even free they’re not much of a value.

Not leather / returning

this was way too big. Even if I put on 6 pair of socks it would still be too big

awful

They were cheap in construction. Plastic not at all leather like in any way. Very disappointed Price was the only good thing about the shou