Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Bay

I own 4 pair of these and will probably buy another color at some point soon. I previously wrote a review but don't seem to see it here. I have very difficult feet (super high arches and slightly wide feet, but not wide enough for extra wide shoes). I live in a warm climate so I can wear these almost year round. They are very comfortable and I can wear them for short strolls or shopping. They are a stylish and budget-friendly version of similar shoes that YSL and Hermes make. Also great for travel as they take up virtually no room in a suitcase or even a tote bag.

Let me start by saying I have big feet. My right foot is a 12 1/2 and my left a 12, so I have to order size 13. I was skeptical about these sandals, because as usually happens, these type of sandals tend to rub my feet/toes in all the wrong places. I was very surprised to discover that I could immediately walk around in them without any problems! I wore them out the same evening I received them and had no problems whatsoever. They were neither too tight nor too loose, they were perfect!

I love this brand. I have sandals, heels, etc. and all are great quality and very comfortable. Definitely recommend!

straps hit my toes in all the wrong places. very uncomfortable and the shoe felt like it was going to slide off my foot at every step

This Sam Edelman shoes are perfect for summer!! They fits perfectly and are very comfy! This are my second pair of Sam Edelman Bay shoes and definitely not the last !

Ok so first off I was a little leary about what size to go with, these type of shoes I normally go up 1/2 size. Reading other reviews I stuck with normal size. LOVE them!

I really wanted to love these, but after wearing them for JUST 3 HOURS, the gold flaked off the leather. These are super cute and comfortable, but I can't spend this kind of money on a pair of shoes where the finish flakes off.

I was worried with my wide foot. These are my favorite and I get so many compliments. I wear a size 5 and wide foot. Love these!

I ordered these sandals in medium and wide width. The medium was plenty wide for my slightly wider than average foot. The wide width was really nice leather. The medium width looked like vinyl/plastic so I am returning them

I love these sandals but they do run wide.

These are very nice and well made. I ordered a wide because my feet are somewhat wide but, the are slipping off my feet. I will be sending them back and getting regular width.

I’ve had these shoes less than 3 weeks and already they are lifting.

These are well made comfortable shoes.

I love these sandals and have them in different colors. Hides my bunions. Very comfortable and great looking

I love this shoe. It is just a little too narrow for my foot. I wish it came in a wide width.

Polished looking casual sandals! They flip flop a bit when I walk, but not too bad. Ordered in 9 wide originally but returned for 9 regular. The center strap kinda hits on my bunions and flares out, but doesn’t make me like them any less. Excited to wear these ancient looking sandals on my upcoming trip to Greece!

Stylish yet simple, good quality and comfortable (not for walking all day though!)

Style is on point and these were so comfy even out of the box- I wore them while traveling in DC and in the airport and didn’t have any issues with breaking them in. I do have a wider than average foot, but not a true “wide”- and these were perfect for me. I want to order the Bay style leopard print ones, I like this style soooo much!! I usually wear a 7, but did have to size down to a 6.5. Love love love them. You won’t regret it! Thank you Zappos for putting up with me while I tried 3 different sizes before keeping the perfect fit!! Your return process is perfection for mom’s who like to shop online during nap time!!

These are beautiful shoes. However the fabric on the footbed causes my feet to slide forward, and foot cushions don't adhere to the fabric. Sadly, I will be returning.

Cute, but felt like they would slide off my feet when I walked, having to do that toe grippy thing when I walked in them, not good. I sized up a half size, but should have kept my normal size.

I am obsessed with Sam Edelman shoes. I have yet to find a pair that do not feel practically custom made to order to fit my feet. they never seem to need a wearing in. And the quality of the materials they used to make them can’t be beat. This is my second pair of Sam Edelman sandals in this style, and I am obsessed with their tennis shoes, heel pumps, and loafers as well. Since December, I just realized I’ve ordered six pairs of Sam Edelman’s shoes add to my collection