Customer Reviews Trotters Samantha

I ordered a 7 1/2 EE and really wanted these to be THE shoe. I needed something a little dressy and light enough to take in my suitcase for travel. But they were tight across my instep. Instead I ended up with the Munro Irianna which cost $100. more. But the comfort factor made the difference worth it.

These shoes run wide. The style is very pretty on, however, when I walked they slipped off the back of my heel.

I am trouble finding the right size. 10.5 too big, 10 W too big, now 10 just hurting my feet. I love the look of these shoes and tried to keep them by walking around the house, but my terrible feet just don't make it. However, they are as cute and high quality as Trotters is known for. I would love them if they fit like my other trotters.

I loved the appearance of this shoe, casual, fun, and I love Trotters, its my go-to brand because their shoes usually fit my 12 B feet well. However, these shoes were too large, I could easily fit a finger between my heel and the back of the shoe. They only had 11's and I took a chance, but these are too tight. Very sorry to have to send these back.

What a pleasant surprise! The photo looked nice, but I didn’t really expect them to fit. I’ve had such trouble lately with length and width. In the very, very olden days I wore a size 9AA/AAAA heel, and of course no one makes a heel sizes now. This shoe was long enough, the vamp was comfy, and the heel stayed just where I wanted it. The replacement spangles that the manufacturer included worried me that the ones on the shoe would fall off; but I decided I didn’t care...just as I rarely purchase suede or nubuck since living in Florida guarantees I’ll walk through water in them eventually. This fit is just so good, I don’t care about what might or might not happen.

I just got these so haven't had a chance to wear them but the fit feels good. I had a bunion shaved on my left foot so often times shoes pinch the area. This feels snot but doesn't pinch. I think they are really pretty. 10 Wide

They fit fine but I didn't like the little gems on the top. Noticed they sent a little plastic container with extra gems do the gems must fall off. Returning for the style.

I loved these shoes; they are so well made; the problem is that they were too narrow across the toes. Previous reviews that mentioned this problem were true. However, I wanted to find out for myself hoping that the width would be okay for me. Unfortunately, the reviews were correct. I had to send the shoes back.

I love these shoes. I have a bunion and had not problem with how these felt. They are so cute, comfortable and they have decent arch support. My only complaint is that although they fit well in the heel and toe, they do gap in the middle. When standing and walking there is a noticeable which usually I don't like at all. However, since these are cute and comfortable, I will overlook the gap!

Too narrow, painful on my heel

Trotters usually fit me well, and these are no exception. I don't always like all of their styles (some of them are a little "old-ladyish," but these are very cute and stylish with comfortable flat heels. They are also narrow enough for me, which is not always the case.

Great style and look. They run long though. I had to put something inside to make them stay on for the dance floor!

I thought this flat would be the design fashion flat, but alas it was not! The toe is too 'boxy' and it made my wide foot look short and stumpy. Like a brick. Back it goes! Maybe someone with a narrow foot would do better. The microfiber material and leopard band are high quality.

I LOVE the shoe...it's a tiny bit wide for a Trotters shoe...I always wear an 11N and it is a perfect fit in all the styles I have...this particular shoe is just a tiny bit wide...but I still can wear them and love it in the blue..

I had high hopes for these shoes for my son's wedding. However, the left shoe pressed into the top of my foot and was very uncomfortable! I've had the same trouble when I've tried other shoes of this style. So I think it's me, not Trotters Samantha.

The shoe itself pinched my toe. If the shoe were cut lower and the elastic band did not cover the actual shoe, it would have fit perfectly.

These are beautiful shoes--lovely soft blue with sparkles--but my heel slipped in them, in spite of trying various inserts and heel pads.

Wonderful shoe and very comfortable with a decent arch support.

The fit and size were good, and the shoes were comfortable. They look a bit better in person as the strap across the toe is pretty much the same color as the shoe.

I ordered a 10 1/2 wide. I was happy to find that size as 10 is too small and some 11's I've tried lately are just too long. These shoes are very pretty yet comfortable. I'm going to wear them to a wedding next week, and I feel the style is subtle enough to wear with a dressy blouse and skirt.

Was happily surprised with the rubber soles with ridges. They were a bit wide for me; I’ve never worn any other width than “B” or average, but they are so comfortable I will keep them.

Love 'em, love 'em, love 'em!!! I usually wear an 8WW but they weren't available in black so I decided to take a chance and get a size 7 1/2WW which I COULD get in black. I'm certainly not advising anyone to order a smaller size than usual, but for me it worked out perfectly! While I love all my tennis shoes with the WW width, they're not exactly what you'd call "dressy". Now I can put on a dressy outfit and have shoes that don't make me look like I'm 100 years old! They're so cute and the design of them with the elastic strap keeps them from cutting into the top of my feet. I love the lower heel which prevents my foot from sliding forward and causing major pain in my arthritic toes. I guess I just love everything about them! I highly recommend these shoes.

The shoes fit perfectly--no play in the heel or tightness in the toebox. The square toe is both comfortable and attractive. Although these Trotters are flats, their style and the sprinkle of sequins on the vamp make them look as dressy as a pair of heels. I bought them in black, and I may go back and buy the blue ones as well. You'll love these shoes.

My Samantha Trotters are just as lovely as I had hoped. The material is soft, and the shoes are extremely comfortable. The "sparkly" decoration on the shoe is pretty and low key; it doesn't look flashy or cheap. Love the square toe!

Good fit so far - the band that has the studs on it at the toebox was darker than it appeared in the pictures. It is black, but looked gray in the photo to me.