Customer Reviews Mephisto Davy

I love Mephisto shoes and have had several pair. I bought this pair and they are well crafted, fit perfectly and are very comfortable BUT......they squeak horribly. I thought after I wore them that the squeak would go away but is hasn't. If anything the shoes are louder and noisier than ever and I hate wearing them. I wish I had returned them soon after I had bought them but I thought the noise would go away.

Mephisto are expensive but great shoes. Comfortable, long lasting, and well made. They run a bit wide. I buy them because I need a wide shoe. Mephisto does not offer a wide in this shoe, but if feels wide. Love them.

The first pair were a little large but all good once I received the 1/2 size smaller. I love Zappo's as it was so easy to return for the right size. These shoes require little break in and are super comfortable. They are not super stylish but they are not built for style but for comfort.

A truly amazingly made shoe. The quality is top notch and they were extremely comfortable the only drawback is the wider width and a seam on the inside bothers me so I had to return. But if you can wear them - they are certainly great quality!

My second pair of Mephistos! Perfect fit and the most comfortable shoe EVER. I also like the fact this shoe is waterproof. Yes, they are expensive, but the quality is top notch. These shoes are VERY well made. Plus, they look great. If you’re tired of poor quality and overpriced junk from China and / or flimsy overrated shoes from Italy, then I would definitely give these a very close look. I suspect the DAVY last a very long time, making the price well worth it.

Mephisto makes awesome shoes. I have a few pair of them. Quality is great and they last a long time. I recently purchased the Cirus in 9.5 and the fit is great. I tried the Davy in 9, 9.5, and 10. The size 9 were very tight, too small. The size 9.5 and 10 were very loose fitting. My foot felt like it was swimming around in them. Great looking shoe. I am disappointed they didn't fit. I love Zappos customer service and return policy.

I was soooo disappointed when I tried on these shoes. The leather is incredibly soft and fine and the soles are perfectly cushy for walking. The mocc toe conforms nicely to the human foot - unlike those foolish pointy shoes. The quality is outstanding. But... they are too wide!! I would consider these to be "wide" not "medium" width. Based on the other shoes that I've been wearing for years and years, I can say that my feet are medium width and these shoes are sloppy on me. I checked various web sites, but it appears that these are available in only one width. To bad. What a shame! Highly recommended if they fit you!

Size 10 too small. Size 10 1/2 too big. Seemed well made but didn’t fit.

Husband has very wide and very flat feet. Found these to be true to size and roomy. Did put own orthotics in them.

Excellent

The fit was spot-on, and love the feel of these shoes. Out of the box, they were quite comfortable!

Perfect fit. The leather and construction are excellent.

It eats my socks, I don’t like that very much. But decent overall.

Size was too small and the width was too wide. Even tried to use shoe inserts of various types to no avail.

The shoe is too wide and too heavy for walking and do not feel comfortable. They feel like a work boot and make you feel like you could fall forward. I've tried adding inserts of various sizes to no avail as they just cause pain in varous parts of the foot.

Shoes were clearly worn before. The top leather was bent out of shape. They were not in the original Mephisto box, nor a Zappos box.