Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Rodney

I really, really wanted to love these shoes. Am looking for flats and leopard print shoes - these seemed like they would fit both wants! I keep walking out of them. I am a 6, ordered 6 and 6.5, thinking I would need to add an orthotic arch anyway. Even w/ an arch inserted I kept walking out of them. So cute, I wanted to love them but am sending them both back.

I don’t know if I’ve ever given a review before but I felt the need to comment on how amazed I was about all the places these shoes hurt my feet. Literally the most painful shoes I’ve ever tried on in so many paces. I don’t think ordering up a size would solve it. Too bad because they are super cute.

I purchased these shoes to replace a pair I have just like them because the others were stretched out. They are my favorites. The prints on each shoe didn’t match and looked faded. The quality was not near as good

The shoes are adorable and the size seemed accurate. That said, the heel is so hard and narrow, making the shoes incredibly uncomfortable and causing terrible blisters. It doesn't seem like the heel will become more flexible after a wear or two, so I unfortunately had to send these back.

The shoes were much more glitzy than expected. Toe cleavage was very noticeable. Not comfortable at all because of where my bunions are. Had to send back. Thank goodness Zappos has a great return policy.

Love these

I love this shoe! I purchased my first pair in orchid from the Rack. I couldn’t resist purchasing a second pair in black!

Very stylish shoe at an optimal price point. True to size, very good quality-on my feet most of the evening with no issues. Highly recommend

Suuuuch a cute shoe! Very dressy without much fuss. I’ve not worn them outside of the house as I’m breaking them in for a wedding next week. They do not have much at h support so, for me, they wouldn’t be ideal for everyday wear.

The fit was true to size (I'm usually a 7 1/2 M and the show was a perfect fit. Loved the style. Comfortable and plenty of toe room although the toe is quite pointed. Very happy with my purchase.

these are great flats. I wear them for work and they match everything. Comfortable as well.

These are super cute! They do have a narrow point to the toe area which caused me to need to size up a half a size. I am extremely thankful they make them in a 10.5. I am usually a consistent 10, but don't mind sizing up when necessary. The original pair I received in the correct size had stitching at the back of one of the shoes that was off center. However, Zappos fabulous customer service quickly fixed the issue for me by sending me a new pair.

This is my 10th pair of Sam Edelman shoes (prior purchases include mules, sandals, loafers, and flats) and my second pair of Rodneys. I love Sam Edelman for the style, quality, and consistent/accurate sizing... all at a very reasonable price. This latest pair of Rodney flats did not disappoint. I’m a 7.5 M and took my usual size. SE shoes are always true-to-size for me (I’ve never taken anything other than a 7.5 M in all the pairs I’ve purchased). The Rodney flats are comfortable and stayed on my feet all day (8+ hours, with a moderate amount of walking) without issue. No slipping, no blisters, no painful rubbing. The padded insole adds extra comfort. My other pair of Rodney flats (purchased nine months ago) have relaxed a bit with wear, so I expect these will eventually do the same, but it was not enough stretching to impact the fit at all. These are beautiful, versatile flats. I love how the pointed toe elongates my legs without feeling uncomfortable on my feet. I can’t stand wearing heels for any length of time, so I appreciate the dressy and elevated feel these flats lend to any outfit.... style without sacrificing comfort. This is a classic, timeless design That will pair well with so many things in my closet, and I expect to get just as much wear out of my (recently purchased) black flats as I have the nude pair I bought earlier this year.

I have two pair of Sam Edelmans and love them! I usually have a hard time finding a correct fit and your shoes never fail!

I bought these for a wedding to go with a long black dress, they were perfect! I usually wear a 9.5 but bought a 1/2 size up due to the pointy toe. I had them on for about 6 hrs- mostly standing or dancing. At the end of the night, on the inside of my left heel, they were rubbing a bit, not sure I would wear them for 8 hrs of walking. Although, if one were to “break them in” that might not be an issue.