Customer Reviews Blank NYC The Astor Cutoff Denim Shorts

I’ve ordered 8 different pairs of jean shorts and these are the first ones I’ve loved. I bought both my normal jean size and a size down based on reviews. I liked my normal size. They’re looser and do stretch as you wear them but i prefer them that way. The length is perfect. I hate long shorts but also have 3 kids so didn’t want crazy short. These are perfect

These run large, but otherwise they're soo cute and comfortable! They're slightly shorter than I would usually buy, but the back of them and the inner thigh areas are a bit longer, so I think they're keepers. I got a 29, and I think I'm going to exchange for a 28. For reference, I'm 5'7" 142lbs and normally wear a size 8.

These are exactly like pictured, but the 28 was a little big, that’s totally my fault for ordering up bc I’d never worn this brand before, I’m confident that the 27 I should have gotten will fit perfectly!! I’m 5’5” 130 for reference

These shorts are cute but were a little too short for me.

These are my absolute favorite jean shorts I have ever owned! I was worried they'd be too low-rise (high-rise shorts don't look good on me) but they are perfect and fit perfectly! For reference, I'm about 5'7 and typically wear a size 4 in pants - I bought size 26.

Ordered them last minute for vacation. First pair was “lost” but Zappos customer service was able to send out a second pair overnight and I had them before I left. They’re stretchy, comfortable and true to size.

Super cute pair of cut off shorts. Great length and covers your rear-end well. Normally I wear a 27 in jeans which can be tight sometimes but not these shorts. I had to return the 26's because they were too big and kept the 25's. They run 2 sizes too big.

So happy with my purchase that I immediately ordered another pair of shorts from this brand. They are super comfy and fit my athletic body perfectly. I typically have the issue where my waist size is a good bit smaller than my legs, but these actually fit everywhere. I am 5’3, 130lbs and typically wear 25/26 in jeans. I got these in a 26. They feel more like 27s, but I like my jean shorts a little on the loose side.

I was sent the wrong shorts. I got the “wedge” which are very high waisted and we’re more like underwear they were so smtigjt and small. Returning.

Great fit very comfortable

Super cute and comfortable!

I am a slim build and these are perfect short but not too short cutoff. Not stiff, but did not overly stretch either.

Best cutoffs ever. New fav. Don’t ride up. Perfect length. Super cute. Need multiple washes, keep this style going please.

LOVE! Fit perfect.

Fit is great!

The fabric is perfect...not too thin or too thick for a summer short. The hardware, color, and destruction are all really great & not too over the top (I'm 45). The fit though...I'm not so sure... I originally ordered a 29...I'm almost 5'7" 135lbs... I knew there was a little stretch to the shorts so I thought these would fit about right after a couple of hours... THEY WERE HUGE! I am not a 28 but I returned the first pair of 29's & ordered one. It fits pretty well but is a little baggy after a few hours. I am certainly not a 27 & was too afraid to return these in case the 27's were way too small as I would expect they should be. Overall I'm happy with these shorts, they aren't cheap... I would definitely say they fall into "vanity sizing" though...

Love these shorts! Run true to size. The most comfortable denim shorts I've ever owned!