Customer Reviews Sofft Selby

Love this bootie!! Looks cute with jeans and dresses!!

I've been wearing my pair of Sofft Selby boots for about a week now, and I love them!! The Whiskey Athens are much a much lighter shade than pictured, but still very smart. (I love the "burnt toe" style.) They're a little bit too large and my foot "lifts" a little bit out of the shoe when I walk, but I don't really know if that's fixable while stile maintaining the ease of putting it on/taking it off. I don't have a lot of experience with high heeled shoes, but I barely felt this "heel" at all, if anyone is worried about that. Arch support is pretty good! And the bed is just So. Comfortable. The boot isn't very warm though, so they won't be a good stand in for thick socks in the cold weather. The only real complaint I have is that the shaft chafes a little bit at the top. For a day or two I didn't wear these boots with tall socks, and no there's a nice ring around my leg from where the edge of the boots scraped me repeatedly. I'm hoping that over the next few days/weeks I break that in, because I'd rather not be trapped wearing tights for the next forever. I definitely recommend these!!

Love these boots. They felt great right out of the box. Wore them for the first time all day.

I ordered these originally in a 7.5 (though I normally wear an 8) due to reading the reviews that suggested one size down. I would NOT recommend this. I had to return and exchange for my normal size 8. Now, they fit perfectly, and I really do love the blue color. Very cute booties! I would go with your normal size on these, though. They fit snugly.

Bought these for a trip that entailed a lot of walking. These were extremely comfortable and I walked for a few days in these with no problems. I love these shoes and the color and would definitely buy again.

Better than I expected.

Love them! They are a greyish-blue, but go well with everything! Easy to slip on and off.

I love the boot, it just did not fit my foot.

This boot is really nice, with quality leather and a beautiful color. I love the elastic on the sides, so there is no rubbing on my ankles.

Cute shoe but to wide for my foot. I have a normal width across the toes and a more narrow instep. They were too wide and did not support my arch enough. They do have a nice soft insole.

Love these boots! Easy on and off, super comfortable, and gorgeous leather...couldn't ask for more!

Most comfortable boots I've ever worn and a great price.

Great boot! Easy to get on. Comortable even for a wide foot. I stand in them all day with no issues. I had to buy a half size smaller than normal.

I saw these in a store and thought they were really cute. I immediately went home and ordered them from Zappos. Unlike some other boots of this style these have some support (which I find beneficial for my high arches). Their height makes them comfortable for trekking around. I have also received a ton of complements. Now that they are on sale, I would definitely recommend buying a pair!

These boots fit my wide feet with high arches, true to size, my feet are size 10 and no breaking in needed! I love how flexible the sole is and yet they feel supportive. I have been looking for a long time for a good boot and was surprised how easy these worked for me, after days of trying on shoes in the shops. Totally recommend these boots!!

I have worn Sofft shoes for some time so I was looking forward to these boots. The leather is very soft and smooth. The insole is Sofft's usual soft but supportive insole. I'm a petite person and the top of the boot came up too far on my leg. I could tell it would be too uncomfortable for my shin. Will continue to purchase Sofft shoes in the future.

Don't hesitate to buy these beauties! For reference, I am normally a size 9.5 in boots, and I decided to keep the 9.5 since I have wider feet. They a smidge long in length, but are much more comfortable than the size 9. Olive color looks just like the pictures. Zappos has EXCELLENT customer service. Best I have ever encountered, in fact.

These boots are both gorgeous and comfortable. I love the fine stitching and small back tab - despite the traditional man's style, they are not clunky and dressy enough for work. They fit immediately with no need for breaking in.

Love these boots! I got the Whiskey Athens. They are very comfortable and the leather looks and feels high end. If you are looking for a casual boot these are the ones.

I have been looking for a pair of paddock boots and found these. Much to my surprise they were priced well below other brands. Sounded too good to be true, so I read the reviews. When others raved about how comfortable the boots were from the first wearing, I thought I would give them a try. You know with Zappos you can always send them back. Boots arrived. Yes, they were comfy but ran a bit large. Easily sent them backhand got another pair shortly. I normally don't write reviews. I just had to share what a great look combined with comfort this boot added to my wardrobe.

I tried on many boots in the same style as this pair. I chose the Selby boots because they were comfortable, of quality, and stylish. Not always a combination that is easy to find. I wore the boots for 6 hours without any issues. I like them so much I'm going to buy them in another color.

These are awesome! Love the olive green color. Love the fact that they slip on easily. Love that they were comfy right out of the box. Love that they look cute with jeans or a skirt. Can't love them enough!

Wish I could wear them ALL the time!! Extremely comfortable and great looking. They fit perfectly and go with everything too! So pleased to have purchased these. They are stylish and a perfect addition to my boot collection. May have to purchase another pair!!

Just got these today and I really like them. I wear a 9 and I ordered a 9 and they fit perfectly-really comfortable right out of the box. They are a hair wide across the top but nothing to be concerned about but if you happen to have a wider foot you should be good to go here. I ordered the grey color and the color is great.

I purchase 2 pairs of these boots. The back pair seemed a bit large, but with thicker socks should be ok. Very happy with the quality and style of these boots. Though comfortable out of the boc, they are stiff and will take a while to break in. The second pair whiskey athens color, were just the opposite, a bit tight all over, but again, could be managed bt socks used. Love them both, but was surprised at the inconsistency in fit.