Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Tinsley

Really cute but too small and narrow. I usually order a size 9 so I have room for my toes (I measure at 8.5) but this shoe has a narrow toe box and didn't accommodate my wide foot.

Cute boots that don't look like rain boots. Dressy enough and don't feel bulky. I'm between size 7 and 7.5. Based on reviews ordered 7M and 7W. Size 7M was way too small and too narrow. 7W was fine with a thin sock. Exchanged it to 8W in order to be able to wear it with a thicker sock. If you leave in CA (warm climate) 7W would be fine otherwise 8W. Don't even try buying these boots in a medium width unless you have a very narrow foot.

These boots are adorable! I would recommend them. Fit: I am normally a size 7 and have narrow feet. I ordered sizes 7 and 8 (since they didn't have half sizes). The 7 felt true to size, but I wanted a little extra room so I could wear thicker socks in the winter. The 7 felt tight with thick socks. The 8 was way too big, even with thick socks. I kept the 7 and plan to buy some thinner wool socks. Style: I ordered both the Sangria and Moss Green. The colors are true to the photos online. They're both kind of muted. The Sangria leans on the purple side of burgundy. The chelsea bits of the boot seem like good quality elastic and are comfortable.

Shoes look great but unfortunately the width didn’t work for my bunion feet.

These would have been perfect for rainy weather if I did not have massive tree trunk sized ankles. They are attractive true to size and width. I was sad to return them.

Comfortable and stylish. I usually wear a 9, 9.5 or 10 and the 9's fit me. I am going to keep them and also get a tall boot. I can see this one getting water inside because of the stretchy fabric on the side.

I usually wear a 7.5 in Sam Edelman flats (and almost every other shoe) so I went for a 7-Wide based on reviews of the boot being somewhat narrow. Super happy I got the wide! I think the 8 would’ve been too long and awkward. The ankle is a little stiff, but they’re rain boots so it’s fine.

They look great and may work for someone with the average foot. Unfortunately they were too narrow, even in a Wide, for my bunion feet. You can see how taunt the shoe is again my bunions on the left foot in the photo attached.

Unfortunately this product was NOT advertised. It is COMPOSITION LEATHER, which is not a COMPLETELY man made material. Therefore, for those of us that are vegan/vegetarian this does NOT meet our standards!! If you are looking for a man made shoe this isnt it ;(

Great boots! Very comfortable and stylish! Followed the advice of other reviewers and ordered them in wide (even though I've never worn a wide shoe in the past), and I'm SO glad I did - they fit perfectly!

I bought these because they are slip-on and waterproof, just what I need when it is time to take my dog out for a potty break. The morning dew is so heavy in autumn and I know my dog doesn't want to have to wait for me to zip, buckle or lace a boot. My feet are dry and comfortable. The red is a fun addition -can't take mornings too seriously in a bright red bootie!

These rain boots are not only stylish but perfect for rainy weather. I received a few compliments on these. And I’m not sure if it was just these boots but they smelled very good on the inside.

Love these. I use insoles Just for added comfort. Totally recommend

I’m actually pretty happy with the boots! After reading through the reviews I decided to opt for the wide version- even though I have fairly narrow feet. Definitely go for WIDE, but the shoes fit true to size length-wise. They are super cute and stylish- it provides a lot of ankle support but that might lead to some chaffing around the ankle. Overall, it’s what I wanted for this brutal Chicago winter!

I have to say these boots are adorable and fit tts or a tad big but the pair I received had the worst rubber/pvc smell ever...so they are going back asap!

I really loved these shoes when I got them (minus the need to wear socks to prevent the boot shaft rubbing), but after a few wears, one of the insoles has started to come apart. The Sam Edelman logo on cloth that is adhered to the insole is coming unstuck. These are so cute, but now I am loath to wear them as the feeling of this cloth bunching up beneath my heel is awful, and feels like it will cause a blister eventually....

I absolutely love these boots! The fit is great I’m usually a 7.5-8 sometimes, but rarely. I followed what others said and got a half a size up and got an 8. It’s perfect but I think maybe even the 7.5 would’ve worked.

Does not run big. I had to size up

Amazing!! They look like leather and are so stylish for something that is convenient to slip on during rainy days!! I have officially retired my hunter boots for these.

I had to size up from my normal size. I wish they came in half sizes. I gave them a 5 star in the comfort dept. because in the larger size they feel great!

I had to return for a full size larger than my standard size. Now they fit.

I LOVE this boot ! It’s stylish yet comfy. If you have anything other than a VERY narrow foot, you will definitely need a wide.

I REALLY wanted to like these but they just felt too tight and I have very slim size 6 feet. Maybe I could have given them a try or order a size up but I went ahead with another brand. But anyway they do look fabulous and worth it if you can find them comfortable.

I am a solid 6.5 and had to order a 7 since this shoe does not come in half sizes. It is a little bit large, but it is made of rubber which is not the warmest, and if I wear it with thick socks my feet fit perfectly. If I wear it with a thin sock, my feet move around a bit. I got these for a trip where it would be raining and they worked great, I actually didn't find them uncomfortable at all which is surprising because they don't offer a lot of support. A lot of reviewers said they feel narrow but I have a narrow foot and I have a very narrow heel so I didn't find that to be an issue.