Customer Reviews Blue by Betsey Johnson Stela

I am a 9-9.5 with a wide toe box (which is why I range in size, otherwise, I'd be a true 9). I bought this shoe in a size 9 for my company Christmas party to add a little sparkle to my plain black jumpsuit. I LOVE THIS SHOE! It's gorgeous...prettier in person! The other reviews about the sizing are likely correct, but it fits my toe box and width problems just fine in the size 9. I'm over 40, so my ankles do tend to swell, so ankle straps can be problematic, but these are NOT! The height is not painful either...I'm not sure what it is, but I find them very comfortable to walk around in and they don't bother my chronic high ankle sprain.

These shoes were everything I hoped for and more. I wore them with my short wedding dress, and received a TON of compliments. They are relatively tall, so be prepared for sore toes if you will be dancing the night away. Betsey has outdone herself with these. Highly recommend them!

I have wide feet, and these tend to hit right at the widest point. But they were surprisingly comfortable for that! Usually when shoes hit me where these do I can't even wear them. I wore these all night to a wedding and got so many compliments on them!

This is an absolutely beautiful shoe. It is even prettier in person than in the picture. It is also comfortable for a very high heel. And Zappos shipping is lightning fast. Very satisfied, as usual.

I absolutely love these shoes! But the heel was just too tall for me. I sprained my ankle about three years ago and wearing heels have never been the same since then. I was tempted to keep them and wear them for the wedding anyway since the ceremony will be on grass, but I could barely stand it when I walked around on my carpet. They are gorgeous and did not disappoint. My dress is a hi low style, so this statement-piece was not going to be covered whatsoever by a dress. Every time I see the shoes online, I am tempted to buy them again because I love them that much. It sucks to get olderm girls.

Absolutely gorgeous shoes! I got tons of compliments on. They are comfortable for about 4-5 hours, then after doing some walking/dancing, my feet started to hurt. However, they were a lot more comfortable than I thought they would be. For the price though, you would think they would be comfortable. If you are looking for a beautiful, quality, head turning shoe - where you do not have to do a lot of walking, these are for you!

For such a crazy tall heel, it was surprisingly comfortable!! wore them for my wedding.

These shoes are AMAZING!!!!! I absolutely love them and cant wait to wear them! They are high but feel comfortable. Im in love!

The shoe was so cute! I typically wear a 7 or 7.5 so I got the 7.5 and it felt a little snug. My feet are also a little wide so the shoe did not fit well. Other than that its a really pretty shoe!

I love these shoes! Unfortunately when I was trying them on with my wedding dress the dresss material kept snagging on the glitter of the shoes. It saddens me to have to return them.

I ordered these for my wedding, and they are PERFECT!! Just as pictured, actually even more sparkly looking, they are awesome. I normally have trouble with ankle strap shoes as my calves are larger, but they fit perfectly. No squeezing, pinching or rubbing anywhere they shouldn't. They feel light as air when wearing them. I plan on putting in a small insole in front for comfort, just because I plan on dancing the night away in them.

Love these shoes! They were too big, so I ordered a half size down.

Of course it's not going to be the comfiest pair of shoes but it definitely is the prettiest! I love it! It's so glam! I even wear it to the office to spruce up the usual corporate attire :)

I have very wide feet so I usually have to size up. I wear a 7/7.5 depending on brand IF it comes in wide. If not, I have to size up to an 8/8.5 depending on brand. So, I got an 8 in these and honestly I could have gotten 7.5. They fit really great and especially for having wide feet. I am in love with these! I bought them for my wedding in a few weeks. So beautiful and have great support. I would say stay with normal size.

Love Love these shoes. Haven't had an opportunity to wear them yet, but do have a dress already!

GORGEOUS shoe. Like OMG I can’t wait to wear them gorgeous!

These will be perfect for my upcoming wedding!

I love these heels! They're truly gorgeous but they are so high that even practicing in them in my house has me almost in tears within 5 minutes. I cannot walk down the aisle in these heels so I have to return them but if you can wear 4.5 inch heels easily go for it. They're beautiful

I love these shoes to NO END. I have them in both colors! I receive so many compliments on these shoes from both men and women. I wear a 7 1/2 and am very true to size, but these I definitely had to get a 7 to get the right fit. That's not common for me, so I can say that these run a good 1/2 size large. Either way, they are magnificent and comfortable and you should own a pair :)

These shoes are gorgeous and not uncomfortable. I overestimated my ability to walk in skinny 4 in heels and that is the only reason they are going back. If I didn't have a 1 year old to chase around at my wedding these would be my shoes.

Very impressed with the quality, style, and fit of this shoe. I’m between a 6 1/2 and 7 depending on the shoe and ordered a 7 in this shoe (as I do with most heels). I feel this shoe fits true to size. The heel is high, which is exactly what I was looking for, and has a generous toe box, which I need. I also think they are quite comfortable as far as high heels are concerned. The glitter is a mix of rose gold and silver large and small glitter sizes. The trim is more of a gold. They definitely have a pinkish/rosé gold hue. I couldn’t be happier with my purchase.

I had ordered these shoes my regular size, let me tell you I had to down size them the shoe was to big, however, they are very comfortable had them on for the whole night of the party!!!! These shoes are a must buy!!!

I get compliments on them every time I wear them!

LOVE these shoes!! I walked around all night and my feet did not hurt!! by far my fav shoes!! LOVE LOVE LOVE!!!

LOVE this shoe! It's even prettier in person. The ankle strap gives amazing stability without making my ankles swell. I danced all night 2 separate evening in these and received many compliments. I found the size true to size. I run slightly wide and not no issues with the toe box. This is by far my favourite evening shoe in years.