Customer Reviews Naturalizer Jaye

This is a good looking shoe that is comfortable.I ordered taupe and like the color. However, they do gape at the sides when walking, particularly the left one. I kept them since I needed a pair of flats right away. This was 2 weeks ago, unfortunately before they were 20% off!

Somewhat stylish and comfortable Navy flats are hard to find for a woman of a certain age. These Naturalizers are a good Navy color, stylish, and pretty comfortable overall after a few wearings to break them in. They are not exactly comfortable right out of the box. I think I will have to wear them with knee highs or tights, which won't work with leggings, but probably ok with pants and skirts. Have hopes that These flats will be ok for an upcoming trip to NYC from day to evening with lots of walking, sight seeing, dinners and plays.

Bought it in a metallic. Coloring was nice. The cut was fashionable, though a bit matronly on me (I'm a 20-something; if my mother wore them, I would compliment her on being quite hip). Honestly, I sent them back because of the Naturalizer comfort system. I've loved Naturalizers before, but these felt like they had a ridge in the center from toe-to-heel. Perhaps it would break in with time and be extraordinarily comfortable, but I was amazed at how painful it was to walk around with that center raised ridge. (I do have fairly flat feet, so perhaps that toe-to-heel was not for me...?)

Lovely shoe - I wear 11N and was surprised that the shoe was too big, especially in the width. Returned them for lack of fit - but they were comfortable and good looking! had them in natural and black, would have loved to keep them both.

See my review on the taupe shade. Toe box too rounded and wide, otherwise a perfect shoe. Sadly, toe box was a real issue with me and had to return the item.

Shoe was stylish and comfortable/supportive; really liked the Nickel Alloy color, as it made for a slightly dressier neutral that would go with anything. And hurray!--the vamp was cut high enough up the foot that it didn't land on the big toe joints or the bunions--most flats seem to be fiendishly cut where they'll hurt the most. However, I ended up sending them back because, as some reviewers noted, they gapped on both sides as I walked. Kind of disconcerting and definitely not attractive. Very disappointing, as I really liked them otherwise.

Very comfortable shoe, true to size and width. I'm forced to wear flats due to a back injury and these are very attractive.

Shoe felt really tight at first. I wear an 11WW. I wore them in short bursts and broke them in that way. Now they're fine.

Nice looking shoe. Seems comfortable...nicely padded insole. Was a little low cut on the inside and therefore was a little sloppy on the fit.

I like the design of the shoes, but they fit at least a half size larger. I am used to buying a 4.5 in Naturalizer (my last 3 pairs), but the same size in these shoes was too big.