Customer Reviews Calvin Klein Gayle Pump

Very pretty looking...beautiful color. However, they are VERY small... and the front is too squished and shows off too much toe cleavage. Not attractive. Much return.

I am generally a 7 1/2 - 8 with normal foot width and these shoes in a size 8 felt like I was cramming my foot in. They were so uncomfortable. The leather is very hard/tough - it did not seem like it would stretch at all. There is no way I could have stood in them all day. I think someone with a narrow foot would be in better shape. Thank you Zappos though for the (as always) incredibly easy no hassle return policy!

this is my 3rd pair of this shoe. I generally love the style and fit of these, however after 8 wears the sole has completely deteriorated.

These shoes look great and are pretty comfortable. unfortunately after less than three months and twenty wears I discovered the soles are completely worn through. I had my prior pair of these for years and never had this issue so I’m not sure what changed but dang I’m bummed. For $80 I expected better.

Ok, first of all, if you don't own these shoes...that is so unfortunate. I am absolutely unsure how I have survived my whole adult life without these. They are the best heels I've ever owned (and I have lots)!!!! Caramel color is awesome!!!! You nailed it Mr Calvin Klein. Thank you Zappos!!!!

I am a fashion consultant and these shoes are one of my favorites. A sharp looking shoe with so much style and the color is right on for the spring trends. My husband and customers absolutely love them. Not a "comfort" shoe, but I can be on my feet for two - three hours straight with no problems.

These are my go-to work heels, I have them in several colors. Comfortable, classic, perfect for the office!

I’ve had foot surgery so I’m careful about shoes! Tan color is a perfect nude on my darker skin. I wear a 9 but these run a smidge narrow and long so I got 8.5 wide. I’ve had them for 3 months now and love them. They stay on, are comfy and they actually match when I can’t figure out what shoe matches!

Super pretty. They are a little snug in the toe; however, I do have small bunions on my feet. They do show toe cleavage but I think shoe is gorgeous. Ok

I was on the lookout for a nice black heel to wear to work so I purchased this item along with 4 other black heels. When I saw the Calvin Klein box I was so excited to try them on however the split second I put these on I took them off and put them in the return pile. There is not much to say about these in regards to versatility. They look nice and that's about it. They are pinchy, narrow, too high, and have zero arch support - If I was planning on sitting all day, perhaps these would be a good fit but that's not reality and there's no way I would want to walk anywhere in these. I ended up keeping a different brand, the Naturalizer - Natalie style that were much more comfortable and looked very similar to these.

I had two previous pairs of this style which ran small but this one, for some reason, didn't (luck of the draw, I guess). I wear a 13 M. There's a reason I bought that many...this shoe is just a timeless, perfect, all-around classic pump. Now that I have a pair that fits correctly, I can wear these all day and into the night with absolutely no issues. Heel is a perfect height for being able to walk in but also be sexy at the same time and it goes with SO MANY things. If you find the right fit, you'll never want to part with these! Thank you, Zappos!

I have probably purchased ten pairs of this shoe for work over the last several years and have been disappointed to note that the materials of construction used have been seriously downgraded recently. Within 3-5 wears, the thin plastic liner around the sides tears (see photo). The soles also crack and wear out very quickly. I like the style, but when they only last a month or two before falling apart they are no longer worth the price point.

The perfect pump! These have become my go to heels when I have a long day. The navy isn't a really dark navy, almost like a slate blue, but I absolutely love them. I also have black and brown :)

I wear a 9 but these run a smidge narrow and long so I got 8.5 wide in another color but kept the 8.5 in these—I’m surprised they’ve stretched a little but tan ones I got did not stretch at all. These black striped ones I’ve worn a couple of times and they are very comfy. The stripes hold up well too. I keep looking for excuses to wear them! The stripes on this are perfect. The cork look is stunning.

Listen to the reviewers who tell you that these run small. They do. I always where 8.5 M and I have to stuff my foot into this shoe box like I'm Cinderella's stepsister or something. I bought my size and one size up. Kept the one size up, sent back my normal size. I recommend going 1/2 size larger than you normally wear. Otherwise, this is a really attractive shoe; a small amount of toe cleavage once you find the size that fits. Heel is a very wearable but stylish height. The little metal bar on the back of it actually adds to the look of the shoe, rather than making it look tacky.

The perfect pair of pumps. 5 star review from me. Size and width are both on the money. True to size. Lots to love here especially for the price. Moderate heel, fairly comfortable for a pump, not a long break in period needed, a decently padded footbed. Great office/work pump. I wouldn't walk miles in them, but there are many more painful options from the competition. Very durable rubber sole and leather upper. Not as delicate a some others. I haven't subjected to pavement yet, but for indoor office environment, they hold up better than average.

These shoes are really cute and fit quite well. I have nerve issues in my feet and some heels cause my toes to squish and then cause significant pain on the bottom of my foot. These don’t do this and feel quite comfortable! And the light blue is perfect!

I love these pumps! The style makes my legs look long and lean. The color (Grey suede) makes me feel like a hundred bucks and goes with a large portion of my clothes. I have two pairs of these and am ready to buy one more (at least)! I usually wear 6.5-7 but purchased 7.5 initially. They were comfortable, but didn't realize they were slightly large until I went ahead and purchased the 7. They are PERFECT. I think these shoes are pretty true to size. The heel height is so comfortable. I wear these shoes to work on a regular and have been able to withstand 8 hours on my feet right off the bat. No break in period required.

These shoes were just want I wanted, but the cut around the bunion on my foot hurt! Can't wear them.

Beautiful red color. Very comfortable the heels are vibrant I’m Happy I bought them!!

Fit and size are true. Leather is nice. Nice navy pump.

Overall, very nice good fit. I went up 1/2 size, but I should have went with my regular size. True to size

I usually have to order a wide. Since there was no wide available I ordered a 6.5 and a 7. The 7 was too long for my foot. The 6.5 was quite comfortable. After testing them for over half an hour on carpet, my feet were not pinched or uncomfortable. I like the 3 inch heel height it doesn't put a strain on my metatarsals or calves. I have not worn them out into the world yet, but so far I am extremely satisfied with the fit. I don't recall any arch support, but I don't buy heels for arch support.

Really fun work heel. I needed a gray/silver heel and I like the balance between fancy but not too bold for work. I am caught between a size 9.5 and 10 normally and I have other Calvin Klein heels that I wear in a size 10. However I tried both sizes and went with a 9.5.

These fit perfectly in my regular size (8 medium) and were exactly what I was needing to wear with an antique rose velvet dress as a wedding guest at a recent fall wedding in the Hamptons. They were also supremely comfy and I wore them all night - including plenty of time on the dance floor - with absolutely zero issues. Totally a great shoe and the perfect height too. I want to buy them in every color now, and I might do just that! The price is well worth it and reasonable.