Customer Reviews Eastland 1955 Edition Newbury

This was the exact style of loafer that I was looking for, and Zappos delivered super fast! So far, so good, though I've only had these shoes for about a month. Hopefully Eastland has improved the sole so that it doesn't crack over time.

I love these loafers! Love the chunky sole, love everything about the styling - the insole is nice cushioned suede with a decent arch support. The sad part is I can't keep them, as my heel slips out of them when I walk...dang! I really like these, and am very disappointed that they didn't fit. For what it's worth I hover between a 9 and 9 1/2, and the 9 fit well, length-wise.

Great style and price ! Also good for those without wide feet but not normal to narrow. Shoe stretches out a little so had to wear socks but not a problem .

Loved the sole on the shoe thought it would be a great winter shoe for ice and snow. The only problem is my toes were rubbing the end of the shoe but the back was flopping on and off my heel. I even tried different inserts to help but that didn't make a difference. I do think the shoe would be comfortable on the person with the right foot shape for this shoe.

These fit my size 10-feet well, and I think they'll be comfortable to walk in for good lengths. Don't think they would work well for wider feet. Color is chocolate brown, more matte than shine on the material.

These fit and feel perfect! Not too snug, not too loose, very comfortable!

Fits great and very comfortable!

Amazing for price . Leather ? Fake leather ? Great for my wide but not wide feet . Unfortunately stretched out even true to size so I just wear socks and perfect ! Great for price and gives me a little height .

This is a very cute shoe even though a traditional loafer. The lug sole and heel give it an elevated look. Very comfortable, not heavy. It fits snug as the box says 37.5 and I usually wear 38 in Dansko but was fine with a days wear at home and I figure the leather will give more with the frequent use these are going to get.

Purchased for work. The comfort is great and the style is fashionable for my style

The heel of the shoe just seemed too heavy. I have narrow heels and a wide foot. so it just wasn't the shoe for me. Super cute though. The only reason I gave the comfort part one star was because of the heel.

These shoes are comfortable and true to size. I chose them because I love the chunky sole, and they look nice with jeans. Happy with my purchase.

Great fit - I have wider feet and thinner back ankles . fit as is for me - 7.5 size so picked 7.5 size . Usually with some dress work shoes have to size up. Stylish and decently comfy .

I ordered the 8M, but my normal size is 7.5W, was hoping the 8M would fit but they are too short and to narrow. Very tight fit. The comfort may have been ok if I could have worn them. Love the style and color of the shoes. Wish this style of shoes would be offered in a wide width, but so far, I haven't seen only a select few in wide and always sold out. I have ordered from Zappos for many years and love the service offered, can't be beat anywhere else.

I typically wear a size 10. I followed advice from reviews to order a half size smaller. The 9 1/2 was immediately too tight when I tried them on. I sent them back and ordered a 10. Upon receiving those, the size/length seemed correct, but I practically walked out of them with the back sliding off my heel with every step. The shoes themselves are beautiful, great quality, love the style, etc. and I wanted to like them so badly, but the heel is too loose and I would have killed myself trying to walk in them. I even tried putting a bit of cotton in the toe thinking they weren't quite a half size larger but perhaps slightly by a few millimeters, but even a small bit of cotton made the shoe too tight - it was just the way the heel was made. I don't have narrow feet or heels, and a medium width tends to work just fine. Too bad. I was disappointed and sent the 10s back as well.

I had high hopes for these! The insole is just slightly off on the arch and they are not comfortable after wearing for a work day. The soles are non slip and nice …. Was super bummed they just weren’t that comfortable!

Shoes does not appear to be leather.