Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

The majority of people liked this shoe and I was swayed by reviews after reading about the comfort, but my foot is not average. The shoe is pretty, no doubt, but it felt pretty flat to the ground with no sole support or arch support. I'm usually a 7 1/2 but got the 8 since I plan to wear in the Fall/Winter. The 8 was way too long and it looked like clown shoes on me (banana shape). I didn't bother getting the 7 1/2 since it felt flat on my wood floor at home. I walk on cement streets and knew I would feel every aggregate of the concrete and it had to go. Not for me.

These are a nice basic good looking ankle boot - though they look a little cheap. The sole was much more slippery than expected - no grip whatsoever. The main problem though was narrowness. I have always taken a medium (size 7½ or 8 M), but these were so narrow that I could not even wear a stocking with them and feel comfortable. The narrowness was along the entire boot. Arch support was OK, if not for the squeezey feel from the narrowness. So back they went.

I am so sad that I have to return these. I have at least 10 pair of Edelman's shoes, and this is the only one that I have been disappointed with. I hate the color. It's an ugly orange.

I sent these back. Soles are very hard, cheap and plasticy, not rubbery so too slippery on the bottom. There were also lumps in the soles like they were poorly made and sealed over a cobbler's nail or something. Looked very nice on, ran a little narrow but mostly true to size. Might order up depending on what socks you will wear. Not good winter booties, unfortunately.

Great looking and comfortable on carpet. Once I stepped on a solid surface, it felt like there was some foreign object in the sole.

So cute and stylish! I wanted them to work but with my problem feet they just were not comfortable enough. I order them half size bigger than normal but still did not accommodate my foot with insert.

Stylish, goes with everything from leggings, dresses, jeans but VERY painful after only 3 hours of light wear/walking. I was really hoping this could be a go-to boot for work and fun.

These are so cute! Would love to own these in several colors! But why don't they make them with a nonskid sole? This sole is too slick for noncarpeted floors (restaurants, shopping malls, etc) and icy/snowy sidewalks and parking lots.

Great look but the footbed is hard as a rock. I'll wear them anyway because the height is the perfect slight lift and they look great with any skinny pant but I may not buy this brand again.

I really wanted to love these shoes as they are really cute. But they aren't that comfortable. I can't imagine running errands, chasing my toddler, and walking all day in these. I wish the shoe was more comfy. These run a bit big so if you are between sizes order a 1/2 smaller.

Very pretty boot; however unless the W width is available, the last seems too narrow and pointy for me. I will make sure to choose round toe next time. Regretfully returning. Also, I think it might be too awkward a height for wearing with skirts, at least with me.

I bought these after reading all the great reviews. First of all, they have very slippery soles so I had to spend an additional $25 to have rubber soles put on the bottoms. Secondly, they are way too narrow for a medium so I had to spend even more money on getting them stretched. I do like the style though which is why I kept them.

These are overpriced, cheap fashion boots. The soles are slippery (no grip) and man-made. Yes, it is a leather upper, but there is nothing by way of construction to be walkable over two hours in a city. I just got home and my feet are burning and swollen. Also! Just because the exterior is leather does not mean that the interior is. It is the synthetic material that actually touches your skin and rubs it raw on the ankles. There is no arch support. I am returning to invest in a pair that will last longer than a year (these will not). I would not recommend them. Sadly the shape of the shoe is really nice, and simple, and frankly I am astounded quality comfort brands like Clarks or Merrell have not taken it upon themselves to make similar basic shooties. It would be really really easy for them.

These are great booties, but too narrow for me, and I can almost always wear a medium width. It must be the tapered toe that is the problem. I am bummed, because they are very nice looking!

This shoe fits well. The shearling feels good inside. The one problem is the sole is very slippery. I had to take my boots to a shoe repair and have the soles roughed up and rubber heels put on for better traction.

Shoe runs a little narrow. Is not the most comfortable I own. Kept the luggage color and sent black back. Style and price make up for some of the shortcomings such as stiff soles and lack of arch support

This boot didn't work for me. I was hoping for a yummy caramel color but it was more of a matte beige. Also, the gap around the ankle was too big - had hoped the shoe would be more fitted in that area so that I could wear with skirts and dresses too. Quality seemed okay, but not fab. Ordered 8 and 8.5 and 8 was the right size - just not a good fit. Bummer.

I have been eyeing these boots for awhile and was disappointed when I received them. I wear a 7.5M and have never worn a narrow shoe. This boot fit fine to the toe, but the width felt too wide, loose on my foot. My daughter who wears a 7W-7.5W thought they fit great! The Saddle Leather 1 color was very nice but the pebbled leather looked cheap for the cost.

These shoes are SUPER cute, but unfortunately had very little support. I bought these to wear to job interviews in the winter, and wanted something with a covered foot so I could walk through rain/snow without worry. These fit the bill, but I think my feet would hurt after standing/walking all day. I tried to put arch support inserts in them, but this makes my foot sit just a little higher in the shoe, which then makes my heel bones hit the back of the shoe at an uncomfortable place. These would be great for someone who doesn't need a lot of arch support. They also hit very low on your ankle/leg (right at your ankle bones), so if you have a little cankle action going on and most boots are too tight on the calf/ankle, these would probably be great! :) Unfortunately had to return them, but if they had slightly more support, I would have kept them for sure!

By reading other reviews, I must be the lone wolf in not liking these boots at all. They look cheap, make my size 8 feet look huge, are cut too straight around the top (more so than they look in the photo) and are too short on my leg to look good. My search continues.

Holy Boat Shoes Batman! I ordered these in my regular 6.5 and they looked so beautiful...then I put them on and it looked like 2 huge boats on my feet. They were so big all over and especially around the opening...so I am going to exchange them for a 6 and see how that works out.

Well I wasn't thrilled w these. Are my feet flippers? Seriously my foot felt so large in this boot. I must be in the minority and I do have a feet that always hurt but these just did not do it for me. My Ahnu hiking boots won't work daily and I am back to the drawing board for a cute stable heeled boot I can stand on for 8 hours.

These are cute but the bottom of the shoes has no traction - I wore them slipping around my house for a few days before giving up. Such an odd omission. They run a little big. I didn't love the style in person and thought the pebbled leather looked a little cheap. Basically, they're not bad but they don't seem worth the price.

I unfortunately have very small feet so it is hard to find shoes that fits. At 4.5, these one did not fit me right. The width of the shoe fits perfectly but around my ankles it was an inch too big, therefore when I walk, my heels slides of the shoes a tad. I'm not impress with the padding these shoes, they hurt my feet. I do not know if I'll be able to walk all day in these. Yesterday I tried on a similar pair of Steve Madden - Ringo and they fit around my ankles very well. The leather on top is very soft which is nice. I am returning these pair.