Customer Reviews UGG Classic Cardy Tall

Great boot! I bought these boots an hour after I saw a co-worker with them on! They are adorable. I bought the oatmeal in a size 7; I’m normally a 7 1/2-8. These are very comfortable and I prefer to wear them folded down, with skinny jeans. They are perfect for the cold winters, but DO NOT wear in the rain or snow. And unfortunately there's no way to waterproof them...or at least I haven't found a way. I loved them so much that I just bought a second pair in black, to go with all my other outfits that the oatmeal couldn't go with.

Ugg's Classic Cardy Review - I love almost everything about the boots...except the sizing. I ordered a full size smaller as suggested yet they still feel big. They are very, very warm!!!

LOVE these boots! They're super comfy and look great with leggings or skinny jeans. The only complaint I have is that they run about a half size larger than the size marked. But I think that's with all Uggs.

SO CUTE-- but not as comfy as I thought - These are super, super cute looking. They aren't exactly UNcomfortable, but the seam in the front of the shoe does feel a little funny. In any case, they are adorable, and I will be wearing them all season long :)

Not as great as they look - I thought this boot was extremely cute with the folded-over button/spat look. Unfortunately it's not that comfortable for walking in. The sweater part on top of your foot doesn't hold your foot onto the sole all that well, so your foot slides over the edges. Plus the sole is stiff so that kind of makes the sliding around worse. After walking a couple blocks my arches ached from the effort of keeping my foot in the shoe in the right place – very much like when you wear your slippers outside on the street. So...it's cute (although it does make your foot look larger) and really warm and nice for inside, sitting in the car, maybe at a football game. Definitely not for errands around town if you're walking.

Great until it rains! It may have been silly to order these boots living in the Pacific NW but they are different from what we think of as UGGS and are really beautiful. If they get wet, it takes a few days to dry out. They came with no product information- so, couldn't tell if they could handle being in the dryer or not. They look great with jeans as well as skirts.

When I saw these online I fell in love with them, especially the mulberry color. I got them and they only have fur on the sole so that means that unless you wear pants not a miniskirt your calves will be very itchy. I figured since Ugg is all about comfort that the sweater knit material be would be so soft. Boy was I wrong. I personally have very sensitive skin when it comes to clothes(but in this case shoes) so I returned them.

Great concept, not very durable - The concept of this shoe is great! And they look great. After about a week, the fabric was already starting to fray. They are also not as comfortable or flexible like other slippers, so it can be hard to drive while wearing them. I would not recommend them for walking around. These are more of a shoe you wear because you like how they look, not how they feel.

If you LOVE Uggs, these are for you! I resisted the Ugg fad for years. I bought some classics last year just to wear to yoga and back when I couldn't wear my flip flops any longer (due to weather) and I loved them. As soon as I saw these, I knew I had to order them! I literally placed the order at 6pm and they were at my door step the next morning at 8am, how is that for FAST SHIPPING! I wear an 8.5 usually, but Uggs in an 8 fit me fine. I have narrow feet, but feel alright in these because they fit like a slipper and your feet slopping around in sheepskin feels good anyway. I have not had a problem with these staying on my calf, although I do not have toothpick legs, and actually usually have a problem with knee high boots being too snug in the calf. My only issue with the crochet Uggs is that they are not reinforced around the toe area, so I have a feeling they will get all stretched out, plus I can see the bumps of my toes and it bugs me, but they are so cute and comfy I can get over it. Now if Ugg would just add some suede in the front of these, we would have a perfect boot! Also, I ordered grey (even though I am a black shoe kind of gal) and instead of all one tone grey it is actually a heathered grey with brown. Although I think it still looks good with black, it will go well with brown. I was more wanting an all grey look – so be warned. I still think they are FABULOUS!

Why won't the leg stay up? I love Uggs; I own 3 pairs. But wanted the Cardy Uggs real bad. Went on line saw them, gotta have it! My only problem it does run big so order down, and the leg part won't stay up, I don't know if it's because I need a size down for them to stay up or what. I put rubber bands on the top, and then fold it down so you don't see it! And that when it stayed up. LOL, but love the boots, I ordered another pair a size down we will see if there is a difference. It does smell, had to spray it. All this for a pair of boots, and I still ordered another pair, I must be crazy or just love shopping and shoes. LOL!

These are not my favorite UGGs. The size fits fine, but the knit fabric is skin tight. I cannot wear them buttoned up because they are so tight on my calf that they are uncomfortable.

A number of reviewers claimed that the boots run large but that was not our experience. We ordinarily would take a 7 but ordered a 6. There are no half sizes. If there were the fit would be better. The 6 was tight.

I agree with the person who was "walking out of the boot" b/c it was too loose all over. I have the 8 and the 9. 8 is slightly too small in the length and the 9 is gigantic everywhere. So sad. :( Wish they fit better, really love the knit style!

I really think these are cute boots, but they kept falling off my feet, so I ended up exchanging them for the Bailey Button style. I have pretty narrow feet, so that might be a reason why these boots kept slipping at my heel all the time. I am normally a size 8, and ordered a size 6. At first the size 6 was okay, but then they stretched out and became too big again. Cute style though.

These boots are adorable, this is my 9th pair of UGGs and while they’re cute, they do not offer the same support as the traditional (Classic Tall) boots. My heels slip when I walk, probably because the soles are heavy compared to the knit fabric of the remaining boot. I wear a size 7 in UGGs and I wouldn’t be able to wear a size 6 in this style so it’s not a size issue. There’s a big difference when the sheep lining does not apply to the entire boot.

They are sized extremely large. I have a huge foot (10 or 10 1/2 wide) and I originally ordered the 10. I had to wear a very thick sock to keep them on my foot... they were too long and too wide! I sent them back and ordered the 9. I think the last time I wore a 9 I was a teenager. The 9 is okay, but the inside is slippery. I prefer to wear Uggs barefoot, but I need to wear a thin sock to keep the boot from slipping. The 9 is a little short for my feet, however, the width is good. I love the style so I’m keeping them, but Ugg needs to redo the last on this boot. The Braided Ugg and the Sundance Ugg have a much better fit for a large, wide foot.

I own 3 pairs of Uggs, including a cardy pair, and a size 7 always fits. I usually wear an 8. I ordered the 7 and it was way too big. I returned for a 6 and it's better, but still slightly loose.

These boots are overrated. They are very cute and I received a lot of compliments. However, not many people noticed that I was walking funny trying to keep my heels down. I ordered half a size smaller, but I really need a full size smaller. The problem is these Uggs don’t come in half sizes. They fit fine at the toes area. Going any smaller would be uncomfortable for my toes. For some reason it’s very loose at the heels. I keep on shoving my feet down towards the heel, but that doesn’t help at all. I feel like I’m flopping around when I wear these boots. I should’ve just returned them.

I ordered the Ugg Classic Cardy and found that I needed to return for a smaller size. I actually also found a better price, so definitely shop around. I ordered the 7 and definitely needed the 6. My other shoes are mostly 7.5. I also found that this boot slips down my calf, and I would prefer that it stay up. Nevertheless, I like the boot and will wear it for a long time. I also ordered the Ugg Suburb Crochet boots. They were true to size, with me wearing a size 7.5 (and I ordered the 7). I would definitely recommend them to anyone who wants warm feet and fashion.

Looks good, but not good for walking - Since these boots don't come in 1/2 sizes, I originally ordered an 8 - I normally wear 7-1/2. The 8 was loose, so I got the 7. It fit well initially, but after wearing them several times and seriously I wore it only 4-5 times, the boots stretched out and there was no grip on the heel. That made it much harder to walk with them as I found my feet were gripping extra hard to keep them on. Really tiring on the feet. For the price I'm paying for Ugg brand shoes, I expect these boots not only look good, but to be comfortable for walking in, but they are not. Unfortunately, these boots have been sitting on the shelf since they stretched out. Like I said, I only wore them 4-5 times. Don't waste your money.

True Review - The boot feels a lot larger than marked. I wish they were made in half sizes.