Customer Reviews Frye Jane Tall Cuff

Finally the perfect boot! These are the second pair of Frye knee high boots I tried. I originally bought the Paige; returned b/c the foot was shaped oddly and looked like clown shoes. These did take some work to get on, mainly b/c my calves are 16 and these are only a 15.5 and circumference, but I can definitely tell they'll stretch. The footbed is very comfortable from the get-go, even though I was nervous about having a heel, they're comfy. Not as tall as I expected, but I am 5'11 and my legs are long, so with the cuff up, they hit just below my kneecap. Per the other reviews, I did order a 1/2 size down and they are indeed just right.

I have these in black. I only wear these 'uncuffed' because cuffed, they are too piratey looking for my tastes. My only complaint is that I wish they had been stored/shipped uncuffed, because there is a fold line in the leather. At least it's not as obvious as the OTK Campus boots I tried (that fold line was horridly distracting). These are the perfect height for me; I'm just over 5'3". They just about cover my kneecap when the cuff is up, so I find they make my legs look longer. I've found that many OTK boots (usually at least 21" high) make my legs look shorter. The heel is just the right height, and the foot bed is comfortable. So, with the exception of that fold line, I'm absolutely in love with these. Oh, and I have larger calves, and don't have a problem getting these on and off. My calves do not fit in a lot of Fryes (Jackie Button, or Jane Strappy for example).

I ordered this boot in taupe. Both style and the color are beautiful, I can't wait to put them on! I wear a 7.5 and don't have wide feet, however I could barely get into the right boot and had to exchange for another pair in 8. It arrived today, but this pair has some grease and glue marks, which are pretty noticeable. I wish the warehouse did better inspection before shipping it out. I will have to exchange yet again for another pair in 8.

I love this boot. Every time I wear them I get tons of compliments. I'm currently purchasing my second pair because I'm so happy with them and want another color. I bought my first pair last year and they have survived the winter. I am not careful with my shoes and these boots are proving to be winter friendly. They have traveled to Seattle, Alaska, new york and even bar night in Vegas and still look great! I agree with other posts that they were a struggle to put on when they are new...like hopping around on one foot praying I you can get your foot through the ankle bend, then employing friends to help pull them off! But after about a month they have stretched and fit perfect. Fashionable and comfortable. Highly recommended! :)

I have been looking for knee high boots for a long time, but inevitably, the flat type makes me feel fat. I'm about 5'5", 130 lbs. with an athletic build. Not exactly skinny thighs. These boots give me a nice lift with the very wearable heel. They are not exactly over the knee, but at about mid knee. I can also scrunch them down a bit. I got the burnished brown. It is not as rich and dark as the picture, but I like them regardless. I bought a 9, even though sometimes I wear an 8 1/2. They are easy to take on and off considering I also have athletic calves that sometimes make things difficult to fit. I think I am in love.

I love these boots. It took awhile to break them in and now they fit like a glove. I get so many compliments on them.

These boots are gorgeous! I love the leather, the pebbling, the heel, the height, the buckle - they are pricey, but should last and last! High quality all the way. They do seem to run a half size small and are a bit of a challenge to pull on but that's expected with the height, I guess. Would highly recommend these awesome boots!

I have seen reviews that said these boots run large; I have seen reviews that the boots run small. I normally wear a 7 to 7.5. I ordered a 7.5 The boots were very hard to get on and off, and when on, they had too much room in the foot area. I then ordered a size 7. Oddly, the 7s are easier to get on and they fit perfectly! Love these boots! Can't wait to wear them.

These boots are beautiful, stylish, and well-made! I receive lots of compliments and love the color. The one thing I didn't like was the slick sole - so I went to a cobbler and had them add a soleguard to prolong the life of the boots! I am normally an 8, but always order an 8.5 in Frye.

While the color of these boots is not as dark as in the picture or what I desired, I must say this is a quality pair of boots. Excellent quality leather and really comfortable to wear. Would definitely recommend!

I bought these boots a while back and am still in love with them. They were comfy right from the start but have gotten even more comfortable over time. I am normally a size 8 but went half a size down with these and put insoles in to take up some space. I do not have any trouble getting them off or on. I have a 31" inseam and these hit about mid-knee, definitely not over-the-knee. The slate color is much lighter than shown here and you're better off going to the Frye website to get a more accurate color representation.

I have had nothing but compliments all day, every day I wear these boots. I had to run to catch a train and they were absolutely comfortable and Frye quality is stunning, as always. The grey color is really beautiful and there is a white protective coating on the boots that can easily be removed with a cloth. I used an old wash cloth and tossed it after.

These boots are gorgeous, but I do have a complaint, and I personally think it's a significant one. They are half a size too big in the length of the foot and they are narrow. I normally wear a size 6 and these boots in a size 6 are way too long for my foot but they're narrow. So at first, I thought they would work just fine. After wearing them twice (so I can't exchange them) they stretched enough that they're too big all around. I got some insoles and that has helped, but I really wish I'd have known this before I purchased them. I read those most 4 or 5 reviews on Zappos and didn't see any mention of this. Bummer, considering the price! I mean they're so pretty and the insoles made them work okay, but they're still way too long even though everything else fits a little better.

Bought these boots for my daughter as a Birthday present. She loves Frye boots. This is her third pair. Ordering from Zappos is the way to go. I have always received great customer service, prompt delivery and items are always NEW, not used or sample items.

I love these boots! I got the dark brown one. The color of the boots looks a little different from the picture on Zappos. Either way it is still a very pretty shade of brown. I get compliments everywhere I go. When I received the boots and opened up the box, I was a little disappointed seeing a lot of white powder on it, and it took some effort getting it off the boots. I called Customer Service to inquire about that, and they informed me that it's a powder the company puts on it so that the leather does not get scratched in transit. I was asked to use a soft damp cloth to wipe it off, and it worked! The quality is excellent, and I can't wait to wear it again. This is definitely not the last Frye Boot I will be adding to my collection. The pure leather gives it such a rich look and feel. You can wear it with an elegant short dress or with jeans and you can look dressy or casual. I would definitely recommend these boots. Just don't expect the color to be true to the pictures on here.

Gorgeous, versatile boots. They will need more wearing to break them in, but they're totally worth the effort.

Love these boots. The color matches black and brown. They make any outfit look good!

What's not to love about a Frye boot? The leather is like butter and the inside is so padded I feel like I'm walking on clouds. I love these boots, very comfortable!

Zappos excellent overnight delivery is the best! Boot all day comfort with an upscale look. Dress up or down, can't go wrong!

love love love this boot. I am almost 6' tall and it's great to find a tall boot. This one comes just an inch below my knee. unfortunately I have a high instep and could not get my right foot all the way in. left foot was fine. I am so sad that I have to return them.

I've been avoiding zipper-less boots because in the past they have been impossible to get off. These are such a pretty style I decided to try them anyway, and am so glad that I did. They come up to about the middle of my knee (I'm 5'2 and take a size 6 shoe), which is perfect for skirts and skinny jeans. And they are so comfortable. I bought my normal size, and can wear wool socks with them. Getting the boots off is not too much of a hassle, although getting them on is more difficult. The other reviews indicate that it gets easier as the boots get worn in.

Amazing! So glad I went ahead and spent the money for these! They are the perfect boot. Immediately comfortable when I put them on. The heel is just the right size to give you some height without sacrificing comfort. I love that you can mix up the look by choosing to cuff them. Plus they look great with skinny jeans and skirts. Oh, and one more thing. I own 2 other pairs of Frye boots, and these are the only ones that run true to size. No need to size down.

I bought these boots hoping they would be a comfortable and stylish go to boot for all year round wear, but unfortunately they never broke in and got quite as comfortable as my other pair of Frye boots that I adore the Carmen Harness Tall. For those that want a comfy boot, keep in mind, these are a much stiffer, hard toe boot than the slouchy Carmen Harnass family of Frye boots. Narrower, stiffer shaft, and a little tough to pull on. As always, Zappos customer service was stellar, and allowed me to return these, without giving me a hard time at all, even after I told them I had worn them a few times, they were able to make a one time exception and take them back. For the cost, I really wanted to love these boots, but when I didn't Zappos saved the day and allowed me to return them. Thank you Zappos!

I own these boots in taupe and love them! They are soft and very comfortable, the entire fit is amazing. Heel is good for walking around and leather is extremely soft. Having said that, I purchased a pair in black grainy leather and they did not fit the same. Leather was tough and it was hard to wear. Unfortunately had to return them! Again, the taupe style is perfect, extremely comfortable and stylish, my rating here is for the black pair I purchased and am returning.

These boots are quite narrow. I always wear medium-width shoes, although my feet are on the wider side. I could barely get them on and once I did, they were uncomfortable. I ordered my normal size and a half size up -- neither fit. The slate burnished leather is a beautiful, neutral color which is lighter than what is shown in the product photos. The leather is quite variable so you will see different patterns/textures/shades on each boot in the same pair.