Customer Reviews Sebago Classic

Handsome shoe. They lasted me roughly a year wearing them nearly everyday. I had the 'sand' color, but it's eventually turned darker - it actually looks better now that the shoes are nearly worn out. Not a ton of support, not super comfortable - but they're do-able. True to size. Put up with a lot of abuse.

Awesome shoes. Very well made, great support, and good fit. I feel like I am wearing socks -- except that the socks are stiff. Be warned that the leather is a bit firm, but these shoes seem to be worth the break-in.

Classy dress loafer - I wear size 15B, so shoes my size are tough to find. This one was comfortable from the moment I put it on, and is a hit with the ladies in my life. Excellent arch support. Expensive and worth it.

Great Product - The loafer was a perfect fit. I have not worn loafers in years due to having a narrow foot, and I could never find a pair that would fit. There was also no break in time. They are extremely comfortable.

Very pleased!!! I really enjoy my new Sebago’s. The service at Zappos is remarkable. With a little mix up in the size (shoes in box were different size than what was labeled on shoe box) Zappos exchanged them fast and easy. Zappos sent a coupon worth $15 toward future purchase for the inconvenience. I've bought two other pairs of shoes since. The Cordo Classic and the Beckenridge. Excellent pairs of shoes. I’m waiting for the Classic authentic brown to become available in my size.

Wonderful comfortable shoes true to size and width. Well worth the price.

Sebago classic penny loafer - Very comfortable. Perfect fit for my B width feet. They last me a couple of years or more.

Waiting a while - I always buy Sebago shoes. After I tame them they last more than I expected. My vamping is too high. I have to correct it with my instep stretcher.

Best Penny I've owned. I've been wearing pennies for over 20 years and all different brands...Johnston Murphy, Rockport, Weejuns, Florsheim. I feel that these are the best from style to comfort. Took a little to break in at first. I have wide feet with a very high instep and the 3E was perfect.

Sebago Loafer - These loafers are extremely narrow if anyone else has that problem! They fit great and are made wonderfully! VERY HAPPY with the product!!!!

SUPER PERFECT! Great classic loafer. Very comfortable. Fits true to size. I'm a transplanted Yankee, so this brings me back to my youth.

Excellent shoe - I've been using this Classics Sebago for more than 20 years and I always found them very comfortable. I use the extra wide model and for me is perfect shoe.

I have loved Sebago Classic Penny Loafers for years, and have owned and enjoyed 20 pair or more. However, the last two pair I have bought have had a raised place in the insole of one shoe making it uncomfortable. I returned the first pair but kept the second. I can't wear them for long at the time, however. I will probably give Sebago’s one more try.

Great business casual shoe - I love the shoe and it is gorgeous; it is still taking a little time to break-in but feels very good.

Too Small - I have worn Sebago's Classic for years, this pair of shoes are too small, short. I have some that are 9 and some that are 9 and some 9 1/2. These are small. I am trying to figure out how to exchange them.

Sebago classic penny loafer - The shoe is everything it was pruported to be. I did find the initial fit to be a little stiff, but that should relax with wearing. The traditional look and leather sole add to the overall satisfaction. The cordovan color is well suited for a variety of clothing colors, and goes well with both grey and tan trousers.

Strongly recommend - Purchased this shoe for my husband for his birthday. His main concern was comfort. He loves the shoes. He was able to wear the shoes for a 12 hours work day without a problem.

Great shoes - Maximum comfort; wear them for 10 years now! The fact that you can order different width is fantastic. It seems you walk on clouds!!

Finally, a good looking NARROW shoe for men - Attractive, well-made, and fits like a glove. Fit was just as indicated by previous reviews.

They were just as described and the comments from other buyers helped me to get a good handle on the width and length.

Finally A Shoe That Actually Fits! I have always had a problem finding shoes that are actually my size. I have short (6-7), narrow (B width) feet. In the past, I would by a size 6D slip on (Florsheim) and use a Spenco insole to tighten them up. I just purchased a pair of Sebago loafers (6.5 B) from Zappos and I'm extremely elated with how they fit. No insole needed to make them fit. What fantastic shipping! I had my shoes 24 hours after placing my order. Zappos is in San Francisco, I live in the Windy City. I'm so happy with these shoes I may order another pair in black. My plea to Zappos is please keep short narrow widths in stock!

Very Good - I ordered two pair of Sebago shoes. One black pair and the other brown. The brown ones are very comfortable, but the black ones seemed tighter so I am hoping to stretch them out a little.