Circus NY by Sam Edelman

I love these shoes. A few years ago, I got a vinyl pair from this designer; these are my replacements. The leather is soft, they are comfortable, and they look great with any outfit. They are for someone with long feet and long legs. If you do not have either, then these might not be the shoes for you. I give them five stars. If I could afford more, I would buy them.

Just felt stiff and like my heel would slip out

They fit well but they looked too bulky and stiff.

Cute! Always a success with SE!

Wanted to like them, were cute and comfy, but have a defect that I couldn’t get over: every time you step, it sounds like someone is wheezing. There must be holes in the soles or something, but I was upset because I had thought that these would be good quality.

Look like a cutie barbie in these shoes, but they are PAINFUL. Great if you're just standing in them. Buyer beware.

Incredibly cute! However, it took me three attempts to find a size that felt relatively fitting. I was hoping these would be comfortable considering they are a pump, ,but it's was a painful couple of hours wearing them. Unfortunately, can't say I'd recommend or keep

Size down 1/2 size

Very comfortable and interesting different style.

My daughter was returning these but really good shoe for her age and for someone who does not do slides or heels.

I sized up a half size and the fit was perfect! Very comfortable for a wedding!

I ordered these to go with an outfit. I really didn't think they would be particularly comfortable but was surprised. They really are and the color is so fun!

Very cute

not comfortable at all around the ball of foot/toes

I have a medium widish foot. The boot fit well in the toe area, not squished up in spite of the pointy toe. I ordered my normal size 6. Very cute boot. I would have kept it but the calf area was too narrow. If you have a normal calf size, this would be perfect. I managed to zip it up (barely) but my 14" calves were uncomfortable.

Sorry to say I had to return both pairs. They are really pretty, but they didn't fit my very narrow center/side foot. The insole is very comfortable.

Super Comfortable just too big. I wear a 7.5 Medium which I ordered. 1/4" too long width great but a have a wide foot

They don’t stay on my feet despite being so very cute, I had to return them

Very nice and are comfortable. I will wear with jean clothing

Each shoe must weigh about 5 lbs. each. Too much for me.

Love these shoes! Add such a pop to any outfit. So many compliments!

Did not like the look in person. Not in my style taste.

I love this shoe. I love the foot coverage. It makes me feel more secure in walking. It would be nice if this shoe was designed with a new tapered toe.

These are gorgeous boots but they had just a little too much of a yellow tone to go with my wardrobe often enough to keep. Beautifully made, roomy in the calf, I wish I could’ve made them work but that color just wasn’t doing it for my color palette. If you’re a blonde maybe they’ll work better for you?

Run extremely large and heel is quite high. Not very comfortable